Cooperstown NY House Rentals on Lake, River or Water Access

Find weekly house rentals on the lake in Cooperstown, NY. We've got beautiful waterfront homes for rent - on the river, on a lake or with a private pond. Find lakefront house rentals at CooperstownStay.com. Search online or call 607-547-6260 for personal assistance.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter any/part of the property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:

- Bed linens, blankets, pillows

- Bath towels

- Television with Cable or Satellite

All other amenities are included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!



Note:
1.  Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host.

2. Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless it is specifically listed.

3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Waterfront


Bass Haven

Riverfront
$2100/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
7.9 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.3 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Renovated in 2004, 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath home with great fishing right off the dock on river just north Goodyear Lake. Wood and tile floors throughout.  Convenient to all baseball tournaments.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Beau Rivage

Riverfront
$4000/week
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
8.4 mi to Dreams Park
11.5 mi to Baseball World
14.1 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Riverfront home located on the Susquehanna River at the head of  Goodyear Lake.  Major renovation 2016-2017. Paddle boat and row boat included.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Eagle River

Riverfront
$1350/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.5 mi to Baseball World
14.1 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Charming waterfront home right on the river.  Fishing is great right off the rear deck. Fishing pole included. Use of canoe, kayak or stand-up paddle board included.  Just 10 minutes south of Cooperstown Dreams Park.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Riverview

Riverfront
$2400/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.2 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Located at the headwaters of Goodyear Lake, riverfront home with in peaceful setting on knoll above Susquehanna River. Beautifully decorated, with an artist’s eye. Large asymmetrical deck over beautiful yard and gardens.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Water's Edge

Riverfront
$1890/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.2 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Located at headwaters of Goodyear Lake. Three bedroom / two bath home with large lawn, enclosed gazebo and large deck overlooking the river. Wireless internet and Central Air.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Winding River

Riverfront
$1990/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
4.8 mi to Dreams Park
17.4 mi to Baseball World
19.8 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Welcoming home perched on a gentle knoll above horseshoe bend in the river. Awesome sunset views over river valley.  Access to river for fishing and paddle sports.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

A Lakeview Paradise

Goodyear Lake
$3350/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.1 mi to Baseball World
11.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New construction. Immaculate, two story home with dramatic lakeview. Hot tub and Central A/C.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

A Water View

Goodyear Lake
$1100/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
9.8 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
13.3 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Graciously decorated 1 bedroom suite with private covered deck overlooking the lake.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Adirondack Waterfront Compound

Goodyear Lake
$6000/week
8br 4ba Sleeps 16
11 mi to Dreams Park
8.8 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Multi-family compound. FKA Amy's Goodyear Lodge & Amy's Boathouse The lodge has 6 bedrooms + 3 baths, Boathouse has 2 bedrooms, 1 bath. Private waterfront w/ 2 docks, 2 canoes & a paddle boat. Game room in Lodge.  Great fishing and swimming.  Zoned A/C + window A/C units.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Anglewoods

Goodyear Lake
$3350/week
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Welcoming waterfront home ideal for family fun at the lake. New kitchen and baths in 2012. One bath is ADA accessible. Two single kayaks, fire pit  and foosball table included.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Arrowhead Bungalow

Canadargo Lake
$1250/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 2
13.5 mi to Dreams Park
27.3 mi to Baseball World
26.6 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Delightful studio right on the water, with all contemporary conveniences. Kayak + standup paddle board included. Open deck overlooking water. Neighbors Arrowhead Cottage - ideal choice for those who wish to be near each other but have privacy.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Arrowhead Cottage

Canadargo Lake
$1850/week
3br 1.5ba Sleeps 6
13.5 mi to Dreams Park
27.3 mi to Baseball World
26.6 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Inviting home with awesome panoramic view of lake. Great fishing and swimming. Kayak + stand-up paddle board included. Located across road from Arrowhead Bungalow - excellent choice for those who wish to be near each other but have privacy.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Aviva's Lakehouse

Goodyear Lake
$2150/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
10.4 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Spend a week by the water in this well cared for summer home w/ contemporary decor.  Accessible waterfront great for fishing or launching a canoe or kayak.  Canoe and 2 kayaks included.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Avonmora

Goodyear Lake
$3250/week
4br 5ba Sleeps 9
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE -New renovation in 2013, this waterfront home has easy access to the private waterfront. Firepit by the waterfront, open deck and enclosed sun room all overlooking the water. Kayak available.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Awesome View

Canadargo Lake
$1750/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
17.3 mi to Dreams Park
31.1 mi to Baseball World
30.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New construction in 2009, located at north end of the lake, with level yard, wrap- around porch. Row boat and paddle boat included.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Barb's Lakeside

Goodyear Lake
$4000/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
13.2 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Barbara's Lakeside is a real gem, perched above the lake with a splendid view of the lake - the sunrise is awesome. Multiple areas for outside seating and dining. Game room, canoe and kayaks provided.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Beautiful Bay

Goodyear Lake
$1600/week
1br 1.5ba Sleeps 4
10.7 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New Construction in 2017. Awesome water view. Great fishing, swimming and paddle sports area. Kayak and basketball hoop included.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Big Pines

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.3 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
9.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Ranch home with large yard, waterfront access with canoe & flat bottom boat.  Great for fishing.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Big Willows

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 6
8.9 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New construction in 2000, with beautiful lake view, awesome sunsets, great fishing. Convenient to baseball tournaments in Cooperstown and Oneonta.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Birch Cove

Goodyear Lake
$1550/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
9.7 mi to Baseball World
12.3 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Charming two bedroom cottage with awesome view and large level yard with basketball hoop.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31