Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos
  • Captain's Lookout view from wraparound deck Captain's Lookout view from wraparound deck
    Captain's Lookout view from wraparound deck
  • Captain's Lookout stairs from deck to water Captain's Lookout stairs from deck to water
    Captain's Lookout stairs from deck to water
  • Captain's Lookout waterfront Captain's Lookout waterfront
    Captain's Lookout waterfront
  • Captain's Lookout deck Captain's Lookout deck
    Captain's Lookout deck
  • Captain's Lookout deck Captain's Lookout deck
    Captain's Lookout deck
  • Captain's Lookout view Captain's Lookout view
    Captain's Lookout view
  • Captain's Lookout waterfront Captain's Lookout waterfront
    Captain's Lookout waterfront

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Captain's Lookout

Goodyear Lake
$3600 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
5br 5ba Sleeps 9
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
12.6 mi to All Star Village
237 Lake Shore Drive South
Maryland NY 12116
GPS: 42.51809, -74.98270
GOODYEAR LAKE - Recently renovated. Perched above Goodyear Lake, any captain has an awesome view of the lake and the hills beyond. This waterfront home has a series of decks overlooking the water; there is room for grilling and dining on the top deck.  There are 2 kayaks for guests to use at the waterfront and they can easily be launched off the bulkhead.

Families especially enjoy campfires by the waterfront under star-filled night skies.

This waterfront home is nestled into the hillside, with the main living areas and two bedrooms w/ bath en suite on the top floor - street level.  Three more bedrooms are below the main living areas.  There is  Foosball table and sitting area adjacent to one of the lower bedrooms.  The yard in front of the home is large enough for playing a game of catch.  There are 7 TVs - 1 in the living room, 1 in dining area and one in each bedroom.

This awesome waterfront home is convenient to all youth baseball tournaments in Cooperstown and Oneonta.

Amenities:
  • 5 Bedrooms, sleeps 9
    Main floor
    First Bedroom - 1 queen, bath en suite
    Second Bedroom - 1 queen, bath en suite
    Lower level
    Third Bedroom - 1 king, bath en suite, private balcony
    Fourth Bedroom - 1 king
    Fifth Bedroom - 2 twins
  • 5 Baths - 3 within bedrooms w/ shower,  1 off hallway on main level w whirlpool tub + shower, 1 on lower shared between 2 bdrms
  • Wireless internet
  • Central Air
  • 2 Washers / Dryers, 1 set on each level, iron + ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 7 TVs- all  Roku 
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Summer kitchen on lower level, w/ table
  • Dining area
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Living area
  • Foosball
  • Side decks w/ outdoor dining and seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Stairs to private waterfront w/ bulkhead
  • Fire pit by the water
  • 2 kayaks + life jackets
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Awesome views
  • 2500 square feet

  • 10.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.3 miles to Cooperstown
  • 10 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.6 miles to All Star Village

  • Please
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity: 9 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly -6 nights: $3600 + tax
    Discounted Rate $3060 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $500

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Captain's Lookout
5 Stars!
Nicole G from IL - 7/16/2021

Plenty of room! Bathrooms in all of the rooms was great. Property owners were easy to work with and very responsive to our needs. Biggest unexpected benefit was a generator when we lost power for 8 hours! Thank you!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jeff N from PA - 7/14/2017

Beautiful view of the lake, great fishing, plenty of bathrooms, plenty of space, 2 kayaks, great back decks. Great family house! My only complaint is the kitchen could use some sharper knives. But I would definitely go back there and I would highly recommend to a friend.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Suzanne H from CO - 6/2/2017

We loved our stay at the Captain's Lookout. The view is spectacular and the home is spacious. The ride into Cooperstown is easy and we loved staying away from the crowds. Thank you for the great accommodations.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 8/12/2016

Captain's Lookout had everything we needed. Great views of the lake and the ability to use the kayaks. Plus was having a separate bathroom for each bedroom. Large enough for us.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from TN - 6/3/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Wendy M from MI - 8/14/2015

It was very clean, spacious and comfortable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from CA - 8/7/2015

Space in house was a great surprise. We were eight family members so all the bathrooms was also a plus. House was clean and fairly well appointed (we would have appreciated a plastic tablecloth or placemats, and a less messy kitchen trash can with lid). The entire staff was friendly and professional. Great week on a beautiful lake. Thank you

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
NancyChirico from NJ - 7/31/2015

Very up to date amenities. We would definitely stay here again. One suggestion a ladder for getting in and out of water For kayaks and or canoes

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from ON - 7/24/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Amy A from IL - 7/17/2015

Captain's Lookout was the perfect spot for our Cooperstown visit. Close to the ball park, beautiful setting on the water, plenty of space in the house. We enjoyed our stay very much!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kyle E from LA - 7/10/2015

Captain's Lookout was perfect for the three couples staying here with boys at Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were close to the Park but able to enjoy the lake and the patios between games. We would highly recommend to all.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from SC - 7/3/2015

The lake and the views are great. The house was much more spacious than we thought by looking at the pictures. The house is well decorated. The water had a little sulfur odor but was tolerable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Angelique n from LA - 6/26/2015

Captain's Lookout was very clean and spacious. The best part was the view of the lake and the kayaks!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Cancellation Policy

GOODYEAR LAKE - Recently renovated. Perched above Goodyear Lake, any captain has an awesome view of the lake and the hills beyond. This waterfront home has a series of decks overlooking the water; there is room for grilling and dining on the top deck.  There are 2 kayaks for guests to use at the waterfront and they can easily be launched off the bulkhead.

Families especially enjoy campfires by the waterfront under star-filled night skies.

This waterfront home is nestled into the hillside, with the main living areas and two bedrooms w/ bath en suite on the top floor - street level.  Three more bedrooms are below the main living areas.  There is  Foosball table and sitting area adjacent to one of the lower bedrooms.  The yard in front of the home is large enough for playing a game of catch.  There are 7 TVs - 1 in the living room, 1 in dining area and one in each bedroom.

This awesome waterfront home is convenient to all youth baseball tournaments in Cooperstown and Oneonta.

Amenities:
  • 5 Bedrooms, sleeps 9
    Main floor
    First Bedroom - 1 queen, bath en suite
    Second Bedroom - 1 queen, bath en suite
    Lower level
    Third Bedroom - 1 king, bath en suite, private balcony
    Fourth Bedroom - 1 king
    Fifth Bedroom - 2 twins
  • 5 Baths - 3 within bedrooms w/ shower,  1 off hallway on main level w whirlpool tub + shower, 1 on lower shared between 2 bdrms
  • Wireless internet
  • Central Air
  • 2 Washers / Dryers, 1 set on each level, iron + ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 7 TVs- all  Roku 
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Summer kitchen on lower level, w/ table
  • Dining area
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Living area
  • Foosball
  • Side decks w/ outdoor dining and seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Stairs to private waterfront w/ bulkhead
  • Fire pit by the water
  • 2 kayaks + life jackets
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Awesome views
  • 2500 square feet

  • 10.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.3 miles to Cooperstown
  • 10 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.6 miles to All Star Village

  • Please
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity: 9 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly -6 nights: $3600 + tax
    Discounted Rate $3060 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $500

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Captain's Lookout
5 Stars!
Nicole G from IL - 7/16/2021

Plenty of room! Bathrooms in all of the rooms was great. Property owners were easy to work with and very responsive to our needs. Biggest unexpected benefit was a generator when we lost power for 8 hours! Thank you!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jeff N from PA - 7/14/2017

Beautiful view of the lake, great fishing, plenty of bathrooms, plenty of space, 2 kayaks, great back decks. Great family house! My only complaint is the kitchen could use some sharper knives. But I would definitely go back there and I would highly recommend to a friend.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Suzanne H from CO - 6/2/2017

We loved our stay at the Captain's Lookout. The view is spectacular and the home is spacious. The ride into Cooperstown is easy and we loved staying away from the crowds. Thank you for the great accommodations.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 8/12/2016

Captain's Lookout had everything we needed. Great views of the lake and the ability to use the kayaks. Plus was having a separate bathroom for each bedroom. Large enough for us.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from TN - 6/3/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Wendy M from MI - 8/14/2015

It was very clean, spacious and comfortable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from CA - 8/7/2015

Space in house was a great surprise. We were eight family members so all the bathrooms was also a plus. House was clean and fairly well appointed (we would have appreciated a plastic tablecloth or placemats, and a less messy kitchen trash can with lid). The entire staff was friendly and professional. Great week on a beautiful lake. Thank you

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
NancyChirico from NJ - 7/31/2015

Very up to date amenities. We would definitely stay here again. One suggestion a ladder for getting in and out of water For kayaks and or canoes

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from ON - 7/24/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Amy A from IL - 7/17/2015

Captain's Lookout was the perfect spot for our Cooperstown visit. Close to the ball park, beautiful setting on the water, plenty of space in the house. We enjoyed our stay very much!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kyle E from LA - 7/10/2015

Captain's Lookout was perfect for the three couples staying here with boys at Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were close to the Park but able to enjoy the lake and the patios between games. We would highly recommend to all.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from SC - 7/3/2015

The lake and the views are great. The house was much more spacious than we thought by looking at the pictures. The house is well decorated. The water had a little sulfur odor but was tolerable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Angelique n from LA - 6/26/2015

Captain's Lookout was very clean and spacious. The best part was the view of the lake and the kayaks!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos
  • Captain's Lookout living area Captain's Lookout living area
    Captain's Lookout living area
  • Captain's Lookout living area Captain's Lookout living area
    Captain's Lookout living area
  • Captain's Lookout wet bar by dining entryway Captain's Lookout wet bar by dining entryway
    Captain's Lookout wet bar by dining entryway
  • Captain's Lookout wet bar and dining area Captain's Lookout wet bar and dining area
    Captain's Lookout wet bar and dining area
  • Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen
    Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen
    Captain's Lookout eat-in kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout kitchen Captain's Lookout kitchen
    Captain's Lookout kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout kitchen Captain's Lookout kitchen
    Captain's Lookout kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout kitchen Captain's Lookout kitchen
    Captain's Lookout kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroom Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroom
    Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroom
  • Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath
    Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath
  • Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroombedroom Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroombedroom
    Captain's Lookout main level queen bedroombedroom
  • Captain's Lookout Main level queen bedroom en suite bath Captain's Lookout Main level queen bedroom en suite bath
    Captain's Lookout Main level queen bedroom en suite bath
  • Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath
    Captain's Lookout mail level queen bedroom en suite bath
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom private balcony Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom private balcony
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom private balcony
  • Captain's Lookout  lower level king bedroom en suite bath. Captain's Lookout  lower level king bedroom en suite bath.
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath.
  • Captain's Lookout lower level game room Captain's Lookout lower level game room
    Captain's Lookout lower level game room
  • Captain's Lookout  lower level dining and kitchen Captain's Lookout  lower level dining and kitchen
    Captain's Lookout lower level dining and kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout  lower level dining and kitchen Captain's Lookout  lower level dining and kitchen
    Captain's Lookout lower level dining and kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom
  • Captain's Lookout lower level twin bedroom Captain's Lookout lower level twin bedroom
    Captain's Lookout lower level twin bedroom
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath
  • Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath
    Captain's Lookout lower level king bedroom en suite bath
  • Captain's Lookout deck off lower level kitchen Captain's Lookout deck off lower level kitchen
    Captain's Lookout deck off lower level kitchen
  • Captain's Lookout  laundry on main level. Captain's Lookout  laundry on main level.
    Captain's Lookout laundry on main level.