Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos
  • Castaway Cottage exterior Castaway Cottage exterior
    Castaway Cottage exterior
  • Castaway Cottage yard Castaway Cottage yard
    Castaway Cottage yard
  • Castaway Cottage waterfront Castaway Cottage waterfront
    Castaway Cottage waterfront
  • Castaway Cottage patio Castaway Cottage patio
    Castaway Cottage patio
  • Castaway Cottage dock Castaway Cottage dock
    Castaway Cottage dock
  • Castaway Cottage dock Castaway Cottage dock
    Castaway Cottage dock
  • Castaway Cottage view Castaway Cottage view
    Castaway Cottage view
  • Castaway Cottage view Castaway Cottage view
    Castaway Cottage view
  • Castaway Cottage waterfront Castaway Cottage waterfront
    Castaway Cottage waterfront

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Castaway Cottage

Goodyear Lake
$2800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
160 Barlow Road
Oneonta NY 13820
GPS: 42.51909, -74.98608
GOODYEAR LAKE - Renovated in 2016. Castaway Cottage is an ideal choice for a vacation at the lake.  Enjoy the beauty of sunrises over Goodyear Lake. Bring your rod and cast away from the 75 foot long private waterfront dock - the fishing is great. Swim from the user-friendly dock.  Discover the fun of a campfire under the stars.  Or simply relax and enjoy the view of the water and the rolling hills beyond.  There is a large side yard.

This 4 bedroom, 2 bath home has three levels of living.  The main floor has living  room, an eat-in kitchen and a delightful enclosed sun porch with rocking chairs overlooking the water.  There are 4 bedrooms on the second floor.  The lower level is a walkout basement - complete with large family room, a kitchenette, a bath and laundry.  The sliding glass doors walk out to a patio overlooking the waterfront.

Wireless internet

Amenities:
  • 4 Bedrooms, sleeps 8
    Second Floor
    1st Bedroom - 1 queen
    2nd Bedroom - 1 queen
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
    4th Bedroom - 2 twins
  • 2 Baths - 1 on First Floor w/ shower & tub, 1 on the lower level w/ shower.
  • Wireless internet
  • Window A/C units throughout
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 6 TVs - 1 in lv rm, 1 in family rm and 1 in each bdrm.
  • Good cell service
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Living room
  • Enclosed sun porch
  • Family room with kitchenette
  • Large side yard
  • 100 feet of private waterfront
  • 75 feet of docking along waterfront
  • Stairs to walk into water
  • Outdoor dining and seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Fishing
  • Swimming
  • Outdoor fire pit
  • Life jackets
  • 2000 square feet

  • 10.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.3 miles to Cooperstown
  • 10.2 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.7 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    NO smoking
    NO pets
    NO team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity:  8 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2800 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Castaway Cottage
4 Stars!
Guest from CA - 6/28/2019

Wonderful location, very helpful owners who responded quickly to questions, comfortable beds, lots of seating, and plenty of efficient AC. One of the best options for rental on a lake with 4 bedrooms. The outside patio and screened porch are both amazing locations for relaxation, watching the sunrise, and having a bbq. For us it would actually be a 4.5 rating It would be 5 stars except for the following: It is an older home, so rooms are naturally smaller than you might expect, and the ceilings are not standard height (more like 7ft) which is an issue if you are a tall family. Also the main bathroom location is not ideal being right off the kitchen and down a narrow stair area from the bedroom floor. Having a sofa bed on the lowest floor with the second bathroom/laundry area made it work for the “seniors” in our group.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jeff H from CA - 6/21/2019

Great setting on Goodyear lake. The house was clean and very nice.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from DE - 6/15/2018

View and Peacefulness

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lou H from NJ - 8/18/2017

Great home. Quiet and relaxing and right on the water. Great time for the kids.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kelly T from NJ - 7/28/2017

We enjoyed everything about this home . It had it all, was clean had great view, very spacious. We loved every second being there.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chantel L from CA - 6/16/2017

The home is well equipped to provide all the comforts from our own home where we were able to be very comfortable. The location of the property was convenient for going back and forth to Cooperstown Allstar village. Loved the home. Brian and Michelle offer outstanding customer service!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Leigh R from MD - 7/15/2016

cute clean house on the lake close to Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Vic W from OH - 7/8/2016

Great condition and owners were professional and easy to work with.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from NC - 7/1/2016

This cottage was well stocked and has EVERYTHING!! Loved the porch and was the perfect place to unwind after a long day at the ball park. Two families shared this cottage and we had plenty of space. This cottage is the perfect package.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jennifer C from CA - 6/17/2016

It's is a lovely cottage and a great location, on Goodyear Lake and a 15 minute drive to Cooperstown All Star Village. The owners were friendly. The house was clean, comfortable and beautifully decorated. The owners provided extra amenities, such as food storage wraps, spices, body wash and plenty of towels, including beach towels. CJ's Boat Rental is nearby and CJ will deliver a boat right to the dock. We highly recommend Castaway Cottage.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

GOODYEAR LAKE - Renovated in 2016. Castaway Cottage is an ideal choice for a vacation at the lake.  Enjoy the beauty of sunrises over Goodyear Lake. Bring your rod and cast away from the 75 foot long private waterfront dock - the fishing is great. Swim from the user-friendly dock.  Discover the fun of a campfire under the stars.  Or simply relax and enjoy the view of the water and the rolling hills beyond.  There is a large side yard.

This 4 bedroom, 2 bath home has three levels of living.  The main floor has living  room, an eat-in kitchen and a delightful enclosed sun porch with rocking chairs overlooking the water.  There are 4 bedrooms on the second floor.  The lower level is a walkout basement - complete with large family room, a kitchenette, a bath and laundry.  The sliding glass doors walk out to a patio overlooking the waterfront.

Wireless internet

Amenities:
  • 4 Bedrooms, sleeps 8
    Second Floor
    1st Bedroom - 1 queen
    2nd Bedroom - 1 queen
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
    4th Bedroom - 2 twins
  • 2 Baths - 1 on First Floor w/ shower & tub, 1 on the lower level w/ shower.
  • Wireless internet
  • Window A/C units throughout
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 6 TVs - 1 in lv rm, 1 in family rm and 1 in each bdrm.
  • Good cell service
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Living room
  • Enclosed sun porch
  • Family room with kitchenette
  • Large side yard
  • 100 feet of private waterfront
  • 75 feet of docking along waterfront
  • Stairs to walk into water
  • Outdoor dining and seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Fishing
  • Swimming
  • Outdoor fire pit
  • Life jackets
  • 2000 square feet

  • 10.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.3 miles to Cooperstown
  • 10.2 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.7 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    NO smoking
    NO pets
    NO team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity:  8 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2800 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Castaway Cottage
4 Stars!
Guest from CA - 6/28/2019

Wonderful location, very helpful owners who responded quickly to questions, comfortable beds, lots of seating, and plenty of efficient AC. One of the best options for rental on a lake with 4 bedrooms. The outside patio and screened porch are both amazing locations for relaxation, watching the sunrise, and having a bbq. For us it would actually be a 4.5 rating It would be 5 stars except for the following: It is an older home, so rooms are naturally smaller than you might expect, and the ceilings are not standard height (more like 7ft) which is an issue if you are a tall family. Also the main bathroom location is not ideal being right off the kitchen and down a narrow stair area from the bedroom floor. Having a sofa bed on the lowest floor with the second bathroom/laundry area made it work for the “seniors” in our group.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jeff H from CA - 6/21/2019

Great setting on Goodyear lake. The house was clean and very nice.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from DE - 6/15/2018

View and Peacefulness

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lou H from NJ - 8/18/2017

Great home. Quiet and relaxing and right on the water. Great time for the kids.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kelly T from NJ - 7/28/2017

We enjoyed everything about this home . It had it all, was clean had great view, very spacious. We loved every second being there.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chantel L from CA - 6/16/2017

The home is well equipped to provide all the comforts from our own home where we were able to be very comfortable. The location of the property was convenient for going back and forth to Cooperstown Allstar village. Loved the home. Brian and Michelle offer outstanding customer service!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Leigh R from MD - 7/15/2016

cute clean house on the lake close to Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Vic W from OH - 7/8/2016

Great condition and owners were professional and easy to work with.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from NC - 7/1/2016

This cottage was well stocked and has EVERYTHING!! Loved the porch and was the perfect place to unwind after a long day at the ball park. Two families shared this cottage and we had plenty of space. This cottage is the perfect package.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jennifer C from CA - 6/17/2016

It's is a lovely cottage and a great location, on Goodyear Lake and a 15 minute drive to Cooperstown All Star Village. The owners were friendly. The house was clean, comfortable and beautifully decorated. The owners provided extra amenities, such as food storage wraps, spices, body wash and plenty of towels, including beach towels. CJ's Boat Rental is nearby and CJ will deliver a boat right to the dock. We highly recommend Castaway Cottage.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos
  • Castaway Cottage living room Castaway Cottage living room
    Castaway Cottage living room
  • Castaway Cottage living room Castaway Cottage living room
    Castaway Cottage living room
  • Castaway Cottage TV Castaway Cottage TV
    Castaway Cottage TV
  • Castaway Cottage living room Castaway Cottage living room
    Castaway Cottage living room
  • Castaway Cottage living room Castaway Cottage living room
    Castaway Cottage living room
  • Castaway Cottage family room Castaway Cottage family room
    Castaway Cottage family room
  • Castaway Cottage kitchen Castaway Cottage kitchen
    Castaway Cottage kitchen
  • Castaway Cottage sunporch Castaway Cottage sunporch
    Castaway Cottage sunporch
  • Castaway Cottage dining room Castaway Cottage dining room
    Castaway Cottage dining room
  • Castaway Cottage kitchen Castaway Cottage kitchen
    Castaway Cottage kitchen
  • Castaway Cottage bedroom Castaway Cottage bedroom
    Castaway Cottage bedroom
  • Castaway Cottage bedroom Castaway Cottage bedroom
    Castaway Cottage bedroom
  • Castaway Cottage bedroom Castaway Cottage bedroom
    Castaway Cottage bedroom
  • Castaway Cottage bedroom Castaway Cottage bedroom
    Castaway Cottage bedroom
  • Castaway Cottage second floor hallway Castaway Cottage second floor hallway
    Castaway Cottage second floor hallway
  • Castaway Cottage laundry Castaway Cottage laundry
    Castaway Cottage laundry
  • Castaway Cottage bath Castaway Cottage bath
    Castaway Cottage bath