Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos
  • Commissioner's Coop deck Commissioner's Coop deck
    Commissioner's Coop deck
  • Commissioner's Coop exterior Commissioner's Coop exterior
    Commissioner's Coop exterior
  • Commissioner's Coop deck Commissioner's Coop deck
    Commissioner's Coop deck
  • Commissioner's Coop waterfront Commissioner's Coop waterfront
    Commissioner's Coop waterfront
  • Commissioner's Coop waterfront Commissioner's Coop waterfront
    Commissioner's Coop waterfront
  • Commissioner's Coop view Commissioner's Coop view
    Commissioner's Coop view
  • Commissioner's Coop dock Commissioner's Coop dock
    Commissioner's Coop dock

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Commissioner's Coop

Goodyear Lake
$2590/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
219 Lake Shore Drive North
Maryland NY 12116
GPS: 42.51913, -74.98110
GOODYEAR LAKE - New Construction.  Commissioner's Coop is an exquisite log home located on the northeastern shoreline of Goodyear Lake.  A wrap around deck on the lake side of the home provides ideal space for dining or relaxing by the water. Bald Eagles and Great Blue Herons are often seen in this section of the lake where they like to fish. 

An open floor plan showcases the tasteful decor.  The living area, dining area and kitchen all enjoy a water view.  Cathedral ceilings on the main level have exposed beams and natural wood  surfaces which lend to the contemporary mountain cabin style.  There are wood floors throughout the main level and wall to wall carpet on the lower level. Two bedrooms are located on the main level, while a third bedroom and a den are located on the lower level.

Guests enjoy great fishing and swimming and canoe and kayak rentals are available close by.  There are window A/C units throughout the main level and lower level is naturally cooled due to being partially below grade. Private waterfront dock.

Wireless internet.

Amenities:
  • 3 Bedrooms, sleeps 6 - 8
    Main level
    1st Bedroom - 1 queen
    2nd Bedroom - 2 twins
    Lower level
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
    Sleeper futon in den on lower level
  • 2.5 Baths - one off hallway on Main Level w/ tub/shower, half bath in the twin room and one on lower level in queen bedroom w/ shower
  • Wireless internet access
  • A/C units in main area and 2 bedrooms on main level
  • Ceiling fans on main level
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 2 TVs / cable / DVD, both flat screen - 1 in den and 1 in living area
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Wrap around deck overlooking water
  • Outdoor dining& seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Private dock
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Parking for 2 cars
  • 2010 square feet

  • 10.4 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.6 miles to Cooperstown
  • 12.9 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No Pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity: 8 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly -  $2590 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit: $400

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Commissioner's Coop
5 Stars!
Kevin P from GA - 6/28/2019

The location was great and the house was very clean!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kevin P from GA - 6/28/2019

The location was great and the house was very clean!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Rick D from MD - 6/21/2019

Very clean and well stocked! We had no issues and it is a beautiful home!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from GA - 6/7/2019

We had a wonderful time at this property. The property was very clean, very well stocked and the views of the lake were amazing. It was a very relaxing stay. We enjoyed fishing from the dock too! It was an easy drive to the Dreams Park (and you make a right into the park which is easier than the cars trying to make a left into the park). We came for baseball but staying here made it a true relaxing vacation experience for everyone. The owner and the property manager were so great with communication that it made everything so easy and no unknowns including general area information!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Irene from CA - 8/3/2018

Comissioner's Coop was a lovely place for our family to stay while our son played baseball at All-Start Village. It was nice, clean, and very comfortable. The lake was a fun backdrop and provided hours of fun for the littler kids. Perfect vacation home.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Diane L from IL - 7/13/2018

Great property in a great location. Very clean, plenty spacious and we enjoyed the swimming, fishing, kayaks and paddle boards we rented easily. It was such a quiet spot with a great view. Just loved it. Highly recommend!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from CA - 6/8/2018

The property was very clean, comfortable, and had all the basic amenities we needed for the week. It was an easy 20 minute drive to All Star Village. The owner quickly responded to a WIFI problem we had. A five mi ute drive to the kayak & paddleboard rentals...very convenient I'll be recommending this to future player parents! Thanks for making our stay comfortable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Melaney from NJ - 8/4/2017

This house was more than I expected. It was clean, the kitchen was well stocked, the beds and bedding seemed new and were comfortable. There was a variety of coffee and toiletries left out for our use. The owner and property manager periodically texted me to see how our stay was going and they promptly returned my text when I had a question. I will definately consider renting this house again when we return in two years!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Frank J from IL - 7/28/2017

Great clean cabin. The ambience terrific. Loved it.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
April R from TX - 6/30/2017

Everything was amazing. It was just like the pictures showed on the website. When we arrived the property manager met us promptly at the house to give us the keys and went through the entire house with us to make sure everything was good. We had a problem with the front porch lights, I contacted the owners and they promptly sent someone to fix them. We have already referred friends for next year. I would highly recommend the Commissioner's Coop. The owners and property were great.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Adrienne J from IL - 7/29/2016

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay here. I would only add some seating to the main living room as this cabin sleeps 8 and there is a three seat sofa and a rocking chair. Also, appropriate size garbage cans/bags for the size of this house would be very helpful. This probably sounds silly, but with cooking for 5 adults, a bathroom size garbage can (and, of coure, no garbage disposal) in the kitchen was tough. The games in the basement thoroughly saved our kids as it rained for three straight days here. Monopoly and yahtzee were a hit!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Julie G from MD - 7/8/2016

Commissioners Coop is a beautiful cabin with a fantastic view! Everything was immaculate! The cabin is equipped with high quality kitchen pots and pans, soft sheets and fluffy towels! Much nicer and cleaner than any rental we've had! The extra touches like the gourmet coffees, gift bags of bath products, and kitchen essentials made our stay extra memorable! Thank you to the owners for sharing their home with us for this special week of baseball!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from DE - 7/1/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from NJ - 7/24/2015

Commissioners Coop was a great place to stay for those going to Cooperstown. it was just enough room for us and the views are worth it!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from NJ - 7/10/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Rachel R from TX - 6/5/2015

This log cabin was beautiful! We loved everything about it! This made our baseball experience exceptional! I would recommend this home to anyone!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

GOODYEAR LAKE - New Construction.  Commissioner's Coop is an exquisite log home located on the northeastern shoreline of Goodyear Lake.  A wrap around deck on the lake side of the home provides ideal space for dining or relaxing by the water. Bald Eagles and Great Blue Herons are often seen in this section of the lake where they like to fish. 

An open floor plan showcases the tasteful decor.  The living area, dining area and kitchen all enjoy a water view.  Cathedral ceilings on the main level have exposed beams and natural wood  surfaces which lend to the contemporary mountain cabin style.  There are wood floors throughout the main level and wall to wall carpet on the lower level. Two bedrooms are located on the main level, while a third bedroom and a den are located on the lower level.

Guests enjoy great fishing and swimming and canoe and kayak rentals are available close by.  There are window A/C units throughout the main level and lower level is naturally cooled due to being partially below grade. Private waterfront dock.

Wireless internet.

Amenities:
  • 3 Bedrooms, sleeps 6 - 8
    Main level
    1st Bedroom - 1 queen
    2nd Bedroom - 2 twins
    Lower level
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
    Sleeper futon in den on lower level
  • 2.5 Baths - one off hallway on Main Level w/ tub/shower, half bath in the twin room and one on lower level in queen bedroom w/ shower
  • Wireless internet access
  • A/C units in main area and 2 bedrooms on main level
  • Ceiling fans on main level
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 2 TVs / cable / DVD, both flat screen - 1 in den and 1 in living area
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Wrap around deck overlooking water
  • Outdoor dining& seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Private dock
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Parking for 2 cars
  • 2010 square feet

  • 10.4 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.6 miles to Cooperstown
  • 12.9 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No Pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity: 8 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly -  $2590 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit: $400

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Commissioner's Coop
5 Stars!
Kevin P from GA - 6/28/2019

The location was great and the house was very clean!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kevin P from GA - 6/28/2019

The location was great and the house was very clean!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Rick D from MD - 6/21/2019

Very clean and well stocked! We had no issues and it is a beautiful home!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from GA - 6/7/2019

We had a wonderful time at this property. The property was very clean, very well stocked and the views of the lake were amazing. It was a very relaxing stay. We enjoyed fishing from the dock too! It was an easy drive to the Dreams Park (and you make a right into the park which is easier than the cars trying to make a left into the park). We came for baseball but staying here made it a true relaxing vacation experience for everyone. The owner and the property manager were so great with communication that it made everything so easy and no unknowns including general area information!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Irene from CA - 8/3/2018

Comissioner's Coop was a lovely place for our family to stay while our son played baseball at All-Start Village. It was nice, clean, and very comfortable. The lake was a fun backdrop and provided hours of fun for the littler kids. Perfect vacation home.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Diane L from IL - 7/13/2018

Great property in a great location. Very clean, plenty spacious and we enjoyed the swimming, fishing, kayaks and paddle boards we rented easily. It was such a quiet spot with a great view. Just loved it. Highly recommend!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from CA - 6/8/2018

The property was very clean, comfortable, and had all the basic amenities we needed for the week. It was an easy 20 minute drive to All Star Village. The owner quickly responded to a WIFI problem we had. A five mi ute drive to the kayak & paddleboard rentals...very convenient I'll be recommending this to future player parents! Thanks for making our stay comfortable.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Melaney from NJ - 8/4/2017

This house was more than I expected. It was clean, the kitchen was well stocked, the beds and bedding seemed new and were comfortable. There was a variety of coffee and toiletries left out for our use. The owner and property manager periodically texted me to see how our stay was going and they promptly returned my text when I had a question. I will definately consider renting this house again when we return in two years!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Frank J from IL - 7/28/2017

Great clean cabin. The ambience terrific. Loved it.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
April R from TX - 6/30/2017

Everything was amazing. It was just like the pictures showed on the website. When we arrived the property manager met us promptly at the house to give us the keys and went through the entire house with us to make sure everything was good. We had a problem with the front porch lights, I contacted the owners and they promptly sent someone to fix them. We have already referred friends for next year. I would highly recommend the Commissioner's Coop. The owners and property were great.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Adrienne J from IL - 7/29/2016

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay here. I would only add some seating to the main living room as this cabin sleeps 8 and there is a three seat sofa and a rocking chair. Also, appropriate size garbage cans/bags for the size of this house would be very helpful. This probably sounds silly, but with cooking for 5 adults, a bathroom size garbage can (and, of coure, no garbage disposal) in the kitchen was tough. The games in the basement thoroughly saved our kids as it rained for three straight days here. Monopoly and yahtzee were a hit!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Julie G from MD - 7/8/2016

Commissioners Coop is a beautiful cabin with a fantastic view! Everything was immaculate! The cabin is equipped with high quality kitchen pots and pans, soft sheets and fluffy towels! Much nicer and cleaner than any rental we've had! The extra touches like the gourmet coffees, gift bags of bath products, and kitchen essentials made our stay extra memorable! Thank you to the owners for sharing their home with us for this special week of baseball!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from DE - 7/1/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Guest from NJ - 7/24/2015

Commissioners Coop was a great place to stay for those going to Cooperstown. it was just enough room for us and the views are worth it!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from NJ - 7/10/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Rachel R from TX - 6/5/2015

This log cabin was beautiful! We loved everything about it! This made our baseball experience exceptional! I would recommend this home to anyone!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos
  • Commissioner's Coop living room Commissioner's Coop living room
    Commissioner's Coop living room
  • Commissioner's Coop living room Commissioner's Coop living room
    Commissioner's Coop living room
  • Commissioner's Coop living room Commissioner's Coop living room
    Commissioner's Coop living room
  • Commissioner's Coop dining room Commissioner's Coop dining room
    Commissioner's Coop dining room
  • Commissioner's Coop family room Commissioner's Coop family room
    Commissioner's Coop family room
  • Commissioner's Coop family room Commissioner's Coop family room
    Commissioner's Coop family room
  • Commissioner's Coop kitchen Commissioner's Coop kitchen
    Commissioner's Coop kitchen
  • Commissioner's Coop bedroom Commissioner's Coop bedroom
    Commissioner's Coop bedroom
  • Commissioner's Coop bedroom Commissioner's Coop bedroom
    Commissioner's Coop bedroom
  • Commissioner's Coop bedroom Commissioner's Coop bedroom
    Commissioner's Coop bedroom
  • Commissioner's Coop bath Commissioner's Coop bath
    Commissioner's Coop bath
  • Commissioner's Coop bath Commissioner's Coop bath
    Commissioner's Coop bath
  • Commissioner's Coop bath Commissioner's Coop bath
    Commissioner's Coop bath
  • Commissioner's Coop bath Commissioner's Coop bath
    Commissioner's Coop bath