4 Bedroom House Rentals in Cooperstown, NY

Play Ball! CooperstownStay.com has 4 bedroom weekly home rentals available for your big trip to Cooperstown, NY. You can choose to stay in a house close to Cooperstown Dreams Park or in nearby Oneonta, NY.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Private Homes / 4 Bedrooms

1 Apple Hill

$4500/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10 mi to Dreams Park
29.8 mi to Baseball World
28.7 mi to All Star Village
New Construction. 4000 square foot home of contemporary style w/ expansive wrap-around deck and heated in-ground pool. Set on gentle knoll with 6 acre well maintained lawn complete with scenic pond and chipping green.   • 4 Bedrooms, sleeps 8 • 2.5 baths
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

102 Trolley Line

$2900/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
1.5 mi to Dreams Park
18.7 mi to Baseball World
19 mi to All Star Village
New construction, 2-story home less than 5 minutes to Dreams Park, just off main road. Spacious home with large lawn, open rear deck, covered front porch, gazebo w/ hot tub and complete outdoor kitchen.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

1890 Fly Creek Cottage

$1850/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
6.1 mi to Dreams Park
23 mi to Baseball World
25 mi to All Star Village
Charming country home in Fly Creek, very convenient to the Dreams Park and to the village of Cooperstown.  Private back yard with deck and patio for outdoor dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Alan's Corner

$2500/week
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
1.8 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
20 mi to All Star Village
Four bedroom home halfway between the Cooperstown Dreams Park and the Village of Cooperstown. Wood floors throughout. Above ground pool.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Amazing Valley

$3000/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6 mi to Dreams Park
13 mi to Baseball World
15 mi to All Star Village
Welcoming 4 bedroom home just minutes south of the Cooperstown Dreams Park with awesome view of the Susquehanna River valley and rolling hills. Spacious open decking overlooking heated above ground pool..
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Artful Cottage

$2500/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
4.8 mi to Dreams Park
26.4 mi to Baseball World
26.4 mi to All Star Village
Artful Cottage is a recently renovated country home with appealing decor featuring modern appliances and amenities combined with country antiques. Large back lawn with trail down to Red Creek. Very quiet location close to Cooperstown and very convenient to the Cooperstown Dreams Park.
Artful Cottage neighbors Artful Retreat.
Artful House is just down the road.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Artful House

$3250/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
4.9 mi to Dreams Park
26.3 mi to Baseball World
26.3 mi to All Star Village
Artful House is nestled in a quiet area on the outskirts of the village of Cooperstown and very convenient to the Dreams Park. This  home has a welcoming ambiance; the well-chosen decor features original art - all arranged tastefully and with style. The yard backs up to a lightly wooded area with a trail leading down to Red Creek.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Artful Roost

$2500/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
3.9 mi to Dreams Park
21.3 mi to Baseball World
20.7 mi to All Star Village
NEW RENOVATION - This Artful Roost is a delightful combination of the best of early architecture features and modern conveniences. Located in quiet residential area about 5 minute drive to the Dreams Park or to Cooperstown.  Good fishing in Oaks Creek at edge of the back yard.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Bavarian Farm Schoolhouse

$2500/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
9.4 mi to Dreams Park
28.7 mi to Baseball World
28.5 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
New construction in 2006 - 7, Three bedroom, 2 bath ,in country setting. Handicap accessible. Immaculate home in country setting.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Best Bet

$3000/week
4br 4.5ba Sleeps 10
1.6 mi to Dreams Park
11.6 mi to Baseball World
12.5 mi to All Star Village
Airy, open contemporary floor plan.  Morning coffee on the deck greets the sunrise and the rolling hills. Dreams Park is less than a five minute drive. Separate quiet areas for work, TV, or connecting your game console.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Birch Hill

$2150/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
11.8 mi to Dreams Park
31.6 mi to Baseball World
30.4 mi to All Star Village
Birch Hill is an exquisite log home nestled in tranquil lightly wooded area north of Cooperstown. Spacious open deck. Great room w/ vaulted ceilings. Awesome view, pool and Foosball tables and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Bridgecreek

Water Access Nearby
$2290/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
3.7 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
21 mi to All Star Village
Bridgecreek is very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams park and Village of Cooperstown. The 5 acre yard is bordered by Oaks Creek which is great for fishing. Very private, quiet setting. Sports equipment provided. Whole house water filtration.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Brookside

Water Access Nearby
$2050/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.2 mi to Dreams Park
25.5 mi to Baseball World
21.9 mi to All Star Village
Peaceful setting in Hamlet of Fly Creek, overlooking a bubbling stream with good fishing. Game room and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Burdick View

Private Pond
$2050/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
8 mi to Dreams Park
13.1 mi to Baseball World
12.2 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2007. Nestled on a gentle knoll overlooking tranquil rolling hills. Enjoy beautiful sunsets from the covered front porch.  Just 10 minutes from the Dreams Park. Scenic pond, fire pit and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Cottage House

$1400/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 7
8.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.4 mi to Baseball World
8 mi to All Star Village
Country home in serene country setting and beautiful views of the rolling hills. Inviting open rear deck for dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Country Hideaway

Private Pond
$1650/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
9.4 mi to Dreams Park
19.9 mi to Baseball World
18.5 mi to All Star Village
A perfect getaway in the country with large yard and private pond complete with paddle boat. Quiet, private setting. Game room complete with pool table + air hockey table.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Creek Island

Water Access Nearby
$3000/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
25.4 mi to Baseball World
22.7 mi to All Star Village
Spacious 4 bedroom / 2.5 bath home with large back yard overlooking Oaks Creek.  Fishing is welcomed.  Multiple decks and balconies, very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams Park and to the village of Cooperstown. Hot tub, basketball hoop, horshoe pits and corn hole toss all included
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Dandy-Li Inn

$3000/week
4br 4ba Sleeps 10
0.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.5 mi to Baseball World
20.4 mi to All Star Village
Dandy Li Inn is a delightful combination of classic and contemporary styles.  There are 4 bedrooms and 4 baths. It is less than a mile from the Dreams Park with a large back yard. Check out Dandy Li Inn Apartment - a separate offering with a private entrance, located in the rear of the building.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Drexel Park House

$1350/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
12 mi to Dreams Park
26 mi to Baseball World
24.7 mi to All Star Village
Spacious Victorian meticulously restored with attention to every detail. Contemporary kitchen and baths. Large rear deck and large yard.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Dunlop House

$2790/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
4.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
22.6 mi to All Star Village
Want to stay in the village of Cooperstown?  Choose this beautifully restored Victorian home with exquisite décor, a short walk to shops and restaurants. Check out Dunlop Carriage House on the same property.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Fly Creek House

$2400/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 10
6.4 mi to Dreams Park
24.5 mi to Baseball World
23.1 mi to All Star Village
Located in the pleasant residential Fly Creek area, large newly renovated home with spacious living areas and modern amenities. Well supervised team party welcome.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Gentle Hills

$2900/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
26.1 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
Gentle Hills sits on large open yard in private location - very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park. Spacious open floor plan with awesome great room for seating, dining and food prep. Basket ball hoop and fire pit. Gentle Hills Apt located on same property.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Gillrose

$2290/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 7
2.1 mi to Dreams Park
21.8 mi to Baseball World
20.8 mi to All Star Village
New complete renovation in 2016.  This immaculate 4 bedroom home is conveniently located halfway between Cooperstown and the Dreams Park. It features contemporary decor done with function and comfort in mind.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Green Acres

$2290/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
18.1 mi to Baseball World
18 mi to All Star Village
Ideal family vacation home with pool, large lawn, swing set, basketball hoop and fire pit.  Recent construction with open floor plan. Above ground pool.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Green Hills

$2090/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
0.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.1 mi to Baseball World
19.4 mi to All Star Village
Raised ranch less than 1 mile from the Dreams Park. Charming, comfortable and inviting décor. Large back yard with fire pit for family campfires.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Ingleside

$2800/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
0.6 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
21.7 mi to All Star Village
Two story home just over a half mile from the Dreams Park gate.  This renovated home is in immaculate condition. Pleasant family oriented decor. Basketball hoop and fire pit.
This home shares use of in ground pool located on neighboring property, Terrace Lawn.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Rabbit Run

Private Pond
$3300/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
9.3 mi to Dreams Park
18.6 mi to Baseball World
18 mi to All Star Village
Delightful country home - newly renovated in awesome quiet country setting overlooking stocked fishing ponds. Tasteful decor - perfect for the discerning traveler. Game room , basketball hoop, and fishing poles included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/31
to
6/7
6/7
to
6/14
6/14
to
6/21
6/21
to
6/28
6/28
to
7/5
7/5
to
7/12
7/12
to
7/19
7/19
to
7/26
7/26
to
8/2
8/2
to
8/9
8/9
to
8/16
8/16
to
8/23
8/23
to
8/30

Rum Hill Manor

$3950/week
4br 4ba Sleeps 10
12.9 mi to Dreams Park
32.5 mi to Baseball World
31.5 mi to All Star Village
Luxury home with breathtaking views of Otsego Lake and rolling foothills. Private hilltop country setting. Exceptional quality, recently built, 5000 square feet, cathedral ceilings, open spacious floor plan.  Screened in sun roo