Photo of Cooperstown Rental Agent, Lonetta

We're here to help!

607-547-6260

M-F: 9-6, Sat: 10-4

Weekly Rental Homes and Lodging near Cooperstown, NY for Dreams Park families.

4 Bedroom House Rentals in Cooperstown, NY

Play Ball! CooperstownStay.com has 4 bedroom weekly home rentals available for your big trip to Cooperstown, NY. You can choose to stay in a house close to Cooperstown Dreams Park or in nearby Oneonta, NY.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Call 607-547-6260
Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!
Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Private Homes / 4 Bedrooms

102 Trolley Line

102 Trolley Line exterior
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
1.5 mi to Dreams Park
18.7 mi to Baseball World
19 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New construction, 2-story home less than 5 minutes to Dreams Park, just off main road. Spacious home with large lawn, open rear deck, covered front porch, gazebo w/ hot tub and complete outdoor kitchen.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

1820 Schoolhouse Farm

1820 Schoolhouse Farm living room
$6000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 12
11.9 mi to Dreams Park
29.8 mi to Baseball World
29.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
An incredibly stunning property! Your enjoyment starts with the beautiful drive up the scenic and historic Fly Creek valley, to the stunning grounds,  with amazing views and sunsets, right on indoors. The renovation inside with magnificent kitchen will surely make you want to cook all week.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

1825 Cottage

1825 Cottage living room
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.4 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW RENOVATION - 1825 Cottage is a delightful combination of a vintage house frame combined contemporary open floor plan and furnishings.

Immaculate, well cared for 4 bedroom, 2 bath home with very large open well manicured field in the back.  Enjoy campfires by the scenic pond.  This home neighbors 1825 Farmhouse and 1825 Barn .
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

1825 Farmhouse

1825 Farmhouse exterior
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.4 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
1825 Farmhouse is perfect choice for families who choose to be in a private setting with room to roam in the large well manicured meadow and fish in the pond and still be be close to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
Guests enjoy gathering and cooking together in the large kitchen / dining area.
This home neighbors 1825 Cottage and is near 1825 Barn .
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

1890 Fly Creek Cottage

1890 Fly Creek Cottage exterior
$1950/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
6.1 mi to Dreams Park
23 mi to Baseball World
25 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Charming country home in Fly Creek, very convenient to the Dreams Park and to the village of Cooperstown.  Private back yard with deck and patio for outdoor dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Alan's Corner

Alan's Corner exterior
$2500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
1.8 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
20 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Four bedroom home halfway between the Cooperstown Dreams Park and the Village of Cooperstown. Wood floors throughout. Above ground pool.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Amazing Valley

Amazing Valley exterior
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6 mi to Dreams Park
13 mi to Baseball World
15 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Welcoming 4 bedroom home just minutes south of the Cooperstown Dreams Park with awesome view of the Susquehanna River valley and rolling hills. Spacious open decking overlooking heated above ground pool..
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Bavarian Farm Schoolhouse

Bavarian Farm Schoolhouse exterior
$2500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
9.4 mi to Dreams Park
28.7 mi to Baseball World
28.5 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New construction in 2006 - 7, Three bedroom, 2 bath ,in country setting. Handicap accessible. Immaculate home in country setting.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Best Bet

Best Bet exterior
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 4.5ba Sleeps 10
1.6 mi to Dreams Park
18.3 mi to Baseball World
17.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Airy, open contemporary floor plan.  Morning coffee on the deck greets the sunrise and the rolling hills. Dreams Park is less than a five minute drive. Separate quiet area for work, TV, or connecting your game console.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Blueberry Hill

Blueberry Hill exterior
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
4.7 mi to Dreams Park
25.2 mi to Baseball World
24.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Spectacular private setting with spacious lawns. Open and screened in decks. Hot tub overlooking front lawn.  Very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
One well supervised team party welcome.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Bridgecreek

Water Access Nearby
Bridgecreek exterior
$2290/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
3.7 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
21 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Bridgecreek is very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams park and Village of Cooperstown. The 5 acre yard is bordered by Oaks Creek which is great for fishing. Very private, quiet setting. Sports equipment provided. Whole house water filtration.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Burdick View

Private Pond
Burdick View exterior
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
8 mi to Dreams Park
13.1 mi to Baseball World
12.2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New construction in 2007. Nestled on a gentle knoll overlooking tranquil rolling hills. Enjoy beautiful sunsets from the covered front porch.  Just 10 minutes from the Dreams Park. Scenic pond, fire pit and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Carson House

Carson House living room
$2250/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
2.3 mi to Dreams Park
22.3 mi to Baseball World
22.1 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Carson House is very convenient to the village of Cooperstown and the Cooperstown Dreams Park.  It features a large welcoming eat-in kitchen w/ glass doors leading to a 16 x 24 deck for outside dining. Basketball hoop, fire pit and game room included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Cottage House

Cottage House exterior
$1490/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 7
8.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.4 mi to Baseball World
8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Country home in serene country setting and beautiful views of the rolling hills. Inviting open rear deck for dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Country Hideaway

Private Pond
Country Hideaway exterior
$1800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
9.4 mi to Dreams Park
19.9 mi to Baseball World
18.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
A perfect getaway in the country with large yard and private pond complete with paddle boat. Quiet, private setting. Game room complete with Fooseball table + air hockey table.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Craftsman House

Craftsman House exterior
$2250/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 8
4.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.6 mi to Baseball World
26.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
This beautiful home is just minutes from the historic Village of Cooperstown. Inside the details from many different renovations are still present and add to the total package. Beautiful trim and hardwood floors, tons of natural light and outdoor dining on the deck.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Creek Island

Water Access Nearby
Creek Island exterior
$2950/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
25.4 mi to Baseball World
22.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Spacious 4 bedroom / 2.5 bath home with large back yard overlooking Oaks Creek.  Fishing is welcomed.  Multiple decks and balconies, very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams Park and to the village of Cooperstown. Basketball hoop, horseshoe pits and corn hole toss all included
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Dandy-Li Inn

Dandy-Li Inn exterior
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 4ba Sleeps 10
0.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.5 mi to Baseball World
20.4 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Dandy Li Inn is a delightful combination of classic and contemporary styles.  There are 4 bedrooms and 4 baths. It is less than a mile from the Dreams Park with a large back yard. Check out Dandy Li Inn Apartment - a separate offering with a private entrance, located in the rear of the building.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Dunlop House

Dunlop House exterior
$2790/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
4.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
22.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Want to stay in the village of Cooperstown?  Choose this beautifully restored Victorian home with exquisite décor, a short walk to shops and restaurants. Check out Dunlop Carriage House on the same property.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Falco's Junction

Falco's Junction living room
$2500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
11.6 mi to Dreams Park
8.3 mi to Baseball World
10.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW RENOVATION in 2020. Spacious home w/ upscale contemporary furnishings and well chosen decor. Game room w/ ping pong and game table. Basketball and fire pit. Private setting convenient to all youth baseball tournaments. Ideal location for families who wish to share.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Gillrose

Gilrose living exterior
$2290/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 7
2.1 mi to Dreams Park
21.8 mi to Baseball World
20.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New complete renovation in 2016.  This immaculate 4 bedroom home is conveniently located halfway between Cooperstown and the Dreams Park. It features contemporary decor done with function and comfort in mind.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Green Acres

Green Acres exterior
$1900/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
18.1 mi to Baseball World
18 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Ideal family vacation home with large lawn, swing set, basketball hoop and fire pit.  Recent construction with open floor plan.
Above-ground pool off the spacious open rear deck.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Green Hills

Green Hills exterior
$2150/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
0.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.1 mi to Baseball World
19.4 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Raised ranch less than 1 mile from the Dreams Park. Charming, comfortable and inviting décor. Large back yard with fire pit for family campfires.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Ingleside

ingelside exterior
$2390/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
0.6 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
21.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Two story home just a half mile from the Dreams Park gate.  This renovated home is in immaculate condition. Pleasant family oriented decor. Basketball hoop and fire pit.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Kenwood

Kenwood exterior
$2250/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
1.4 mi to Dreams Park
20.8 mi to Baseball World
20.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Kenwood - a delightful combination of vintage architecture and contemporary decor and furnishings. This 4 bedroom home is very convenient to the Dreams Park and the village of Cooperstown. New ownership in fall of 2019.

A game room in a separate outbuilding has air hockey and ping pong.  There is a very large back yard for pick-up games.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Middlefield Hill

Middlefield Hill exterior
$1980/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
12.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.3 mi to Baseball World
24.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Peaceful, private location w/ scenic long distance views. 2 small fishing ponds. Immaculate home w/ 2 wings - great for families who wish to be near each other but have their privacy. 6 TVs, large outside area.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Rabbit Run

Private Pond
Rabbit Run exterior
$3900/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
9.3 mi to Dreams Park
18.6 mi to Baseball World
18 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Delightful country home - newly renovated in awesome quiet country setting overlooking stocked fishing ponds. Tasteful decor - perfect for the discerning traveler. Game room , basketball hoop, and fishing poles included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Sky View

Sky View exterior
$1850/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
5 mi to Dreams Park
17.4 mi to Baseball World
17.2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Pristine ranch perched high on top of a gentle rolling hill with spectacular panoramic 360 degree views.  Peaceful country setting in prime location, very convenient to the Dreams Park. An exclusive property set on over 200 acres. Stay at your own private hill-top retreat!
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Stagg House

Private Pond
Victory Hill exterior
$2000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
13.4 mi to Baseball World
16 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Stagg House, FKA Victory Hill - under new ownership in 2020.
A frame home with new addition in quiet country setting.  Fire pit, acres of meadows and woods for exploring. Private pond for fishing - fishing gear provided. 
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

The Lodge

Private Pond
The Lodge exterior
$3600/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 8
8.7 mi to Dreams Park
12.1 mi to Baseball World
15.1 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
The Lodge is a very unique offering with it's own 8 acre private lake.  Interior features vaulted ceiling of timbers in the great room and ceilings throughout. Large wrap-around covered porch, partially screened-in. Canoes, and fishing poles provided.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

The Shire

The Shire exterior
$2200/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 8
3.8 mi to Dreams Park
15.7 mi to Baseball World
15.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Charming renovated 4 bedroom home with contemporary décor in Milford.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Thistle Hill

Thistle Hill exterior
$3500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 12
3.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.1 mi to Baseball World
19.4 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New construction - Exquisite country home very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams Park. Upscale decor - sure to please discerning guests. Awesome long distance view, outdoor covered patio, fire pit and indoor game room.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Wake Robin Cottage

Wake Robin Cottage living room
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 4.5ba Sleeps 9
10 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
12.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Unique 4 bedroom / 4 bath home. Spacious common areas - with open flow from living to dining area. One bedroom with bath en suite on first floor; remaining 3 bedrooms & baths on second floor.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

5 Acre Pines

5 Acre Pines exterior
$2900/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 12
19.1 mi to Dreams Park
7.3 mi to Baseball World
9.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Fun filled property with large yards, basketball hoop, fire pits and above ground pool.  Convenient to Oneonta baseball tournaments.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Alana Bertch Cottage

Alana Bertch Cottage living room
$2050/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 8
22 mi to Dreams Park
5.8 mi to Baseball World
2.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW RENOVATION - Less than a 5 minute drive to All Star Village.  Convenient to shops and restaurants in Oneonta. Welcoming contemporary decor. Open floor plan, spacious deck and covered breezeway for outside dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Alexia

Alexa patio overlooking pool
$3750/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
21 mi to Dreams Park
3.3 mi to Baseball World
1.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Alexia is a modern home of NEW  construction with upscale decor, contemporary conveniences.  The awesome back yard features an asymmetrically shaped in-ground pool, with lots of seating for lounging or outside dining.
This home neighbors Arianna which also has an in-ground pool.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

All Stars Retreat

All Stars Retreat exterior
$1290/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 1.5ba Sleeps 8
18.9 mi to Dreams Park
1.2 mi to Baseball World
5.6 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Located in a quiet residential area of Oneonta, All Stars Retreat is very convenient to baseball tournaments in Oneonta.  A short walk to Wilbur Park public swimming pool as well as shops and restaurants.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Aprita

Aprita exterior
$2500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
20.1 mi to Dreams Park
4.8 mi to Baseball World
1.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Aprita is located less than 5 minutes from All Star Village in quiet residential setting. Covered front and rear porches.  Delightful combination of vintage architectural features with contemporary amenities and decor!
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Ark Place

Ark Place living room
$1990/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
19.1 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
6.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Tucked up in the rolling hills outside of Oneonta, this property is convenient to the baseball tournaments, but enjoys the quiet of the country. Modern decor and great outdoor space allow for relaxation and enjoyment. 
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Athletes' Place

Athletes' Place exterior
$2850/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 8
20.1 mi to Dreams Park
4.9 mi to Baseball World
1.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
New Renovation - Features a first floor open floor plan with spacious great room for living and kitchen area. Screened in sun room overlooking large well maintained back yard. Basketball hoop included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Big Oak

Big Oak exterior
$1990/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 10
22.3 mi to Dreams Park
7.4 mi to Baseball World
3.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW RENOVATION - Welcoming 4 bedroom / 3 bath home w large eat-in kitchen, spacious living room. Two decks and a covered front porch provide relaxing outside areas for enjoyment of fresh country air and views of rolling hills.
Game room with pool, ping-pong and air hockey.  Outside fire pit for family campfires under the stars.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Chestnut Ridge

Chestnut Ridge living room
$2000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
19.3 mi to Dreams Park
1.7 mi to Baseball World
2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW RENOVATION in 2019. Inviting contemporary decor. Four queen bedrooms, two baths.  360 square foot deck for outside dining & seating.  Very convenient to All Star Village and Baseball World in Oneonta.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Cooper Creek

Cooper Creek Great Room
$2500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
20.1 mi to Dreams Park
7.4 mi to Baseball World
3.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Cooper Creek is very convenient to All Star Village.  Welcoming 4 bdrm / 2 bath home featuring spacious sun room with plenty of room for dining and relaxing. Open rear deck w/ roll down awning for outdoor dining & relaxing.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Cottage on the Hill

Cottage on the Hill rear deck
$1890/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 6
16.4 mi to Dreams Park
3.8 mi to Baseball World
4.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
NEW Renovation - modern design and decor and a little bit of quiet in a country setting make this a great choice. Short drive to both Oneonta baseball tournaments and shops and restaurants. 
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Emmons Hill

Emmons Hill living room
$3900/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 10
16.3 mi to Dreams Park
5 mi to Baseball World
7.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Ideal choice for discerning traveler seeking spacious contemporary home with awesome interior and outside areas. Private setting convenient to youth baseball tournaments. Hot tub + gas fire pit included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Hemlock

Hemlock exterior
$1650/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
14.9 mi to Dreams Park
5.8 mi to Baseball World
8.2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Four bedroom / 2 bath home in quiet residential area.  Spacious lawns with outside dining and fire pit.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Shagbark Hill

Shagbark Hill exterior
$3350/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 12
19.1 mi to Dreams Park
4.2 mi to Baseball World
0.9 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
Less than a mile from All Star Village, family friendly home on 8 acre lot with awesome long distance views of rolling hills. Basketball hoop included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Bass Haven

Riverfront
Bass Haven exterior
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
7.9 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Renovated in 2004, 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath home with great fishing right off the dock on river just north Goodyear Lake. Wood and tile floors throughout.  Convenient to all baseball tournaments. 
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Riverview

Riverfront
Riverview exterior
$2450/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Located at the headwaters of Goodyear Lake, riverfront home with in peaceful setting on knoll above Susquehanna River. Beautifully decorated, with an artist’s eye. Large asymmetrical deck over beautiful yard and gardens.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Winding River

Riverfront
Winding River exterior
$2190/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
4.8 mi to Dreams Park
17.4 mi to Baseball World
19.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Welcoming home perched on a gentle knoll above horseshoe bend in the river. Awesome sunset views over river valley.  Access to river for fishing and paddle sports.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

3 Ducks on a Lake

Goodyear Lake
3 Ducks on a lake exterior
$2850/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.4 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - NEW construction 2019. Modern design and furnishings, lake access just steps from your porch. 
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

A Lakeview Paradise

Goodyear Lake
A Lakeview Paradise exterior
$4000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.1 mi to Baseball World
11.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - New construction. Immaculate, two story home with dramatic lakeview. Hot tub and Central A/C.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Avonmora

Goodyear Lake
Avonmora exterior
$3600/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
5br 5ba Sleeps 9
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE -New renovation in 2013, this waterfront home has easy access to the private waterfront. Firepit by the waterfront, open deck and enclosed sun room all overlooking the water. Kayak available.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Barb's Lakeside

Goodyear Lake
Barbara's Lakeside exterior
$4000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
13.2 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - Barbara's Lakeside is a real gem, perched above the lake with a splendid view of the lake - the sunrise is awesome. Multiple areas for outside seating and dining. Game room, canoe and kayaks provided.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Castaway Cottage

Goodyear Lake
Castaway Cottage exterior
$2800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - Renovated in 2016. Conveniently located to all baseball tournaments. 100 feet of private waterfront. Patio overlooking the water is ideal for outdoor dining and relaxing. Outdoor fire pit provides campfire time for the whole family.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Fisher's Landing

Canadargo Lake
Fisher's Landing exterior
$3300/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 11
13.1 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
27.3 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

CANADARAGO LAKE - Fisher's Landing was remodeled in 2011 with contemporary kitchen and baths. Awesome views and waterfront make it an ideal family vacation choice.

Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Friendship Lodge

Goodyear Lake
Friendship Lodge exterior
$4700/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.8 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE -Built in 2005, exquisite spacious waterfront home with large yard, covered porch and extensive waterfront docks and decks. Canoe included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Goodyear Getaway

Goodyear Lake
Goodyear Getaway exterior
$3800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
11.2 mi to Baseball World
13.7 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - New Construction - Spacious home with open rear deck, 1 acre well maintained lawn, basketball hoop, fire pit, private waterfront, and canoe.  Phenomenal fishing. Game room w/ pool table, Foosball, air hockey, slot machines + arcade games.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Morning Glory

Canadargo Lake
Morning Glory early morning
$2100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
13.4 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
26.5 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
CANADARAGO LAKE - Renovated in 2016-17. Phenomenal sunrise start each day with Morning Glory! 250 sq ft covered balcony overlooking lake with eastern view. Great swimming, fishing from private dock.  Row boat, paddle-boat, 2 kayaks, fishing poles and tackle provided.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Riverbend

Goodyear Lake
Riverbend exterior
$3990/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
8.9 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2014, awesome 4 bedroom, 3 bath home enjoys great sunset views,awesome fishing, open floor plan designed for family fun! Game room, paddle boat, private 100 foot waterfront with dock.  Fire pit for family campfires.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

Anglewoods

Goodyear Lake
Anglewoods exterior
$3500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
View Rental
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us
GOODYEAR LAKE - Welcoming waterfront home ideal for family fun at the lake. Recently renovated kitchen and baths. One bath is ADA accessible. Two single kayaks, fire pit  and foosball table included.
Availability In 2021 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2021 Reservations Begin October 1, 2020
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Help: Call 607-547-6260 or Email Us

4 Bedroom
MASTER LIST...
102 Trolley Line
1820 Schoolhouse Farm
1825 Cottage
1825 Farmhouse
1890 Fly Creek Cottage
Alan's Corner
Amazing Valley
Bavarian Farm Schoolhouse
Best Bet
Blueberry Hill
Bridgecreek
Burdick View
Carson House
Cottage House
Country Hideaway
Craftsman House
Creek Island
Dandy-Li Inn
Dunlop House
Falco's Junction
Gillrose
Green Acres
Green Hills
Ingleside
Kenwood
Middlefield Hill
Rabbit Run
Sky View
Stagg House
The Lodge
The Shire
Thistle Hill
Wake Robin Cottage

Other 4 Bedroom
Oneonta
5 Acre Pines
Alana Bertch Cottage
Alexia
All Stars Retreat
Aprita
Ark Place
Athletes' Place
Big Oak
Chestnut Ridge
Cooper Creek
Cottage on the Hill
Emmons Hill
Hemlock
Shagbark Hill
Riverfront
Bass Haven
Riverview
Winding River
Lakefront
3 Ducks on a Lake
A Lakeview Paradise
Avonmora
Barb's Lakeside
Castaway Cottage
Fisher's Landing
Friendship Lodge
Goodyear Getaway
Morning Glory
Riverbend
Lakefront
Anglewoods