4 Bedroom House Rentals in Cooperstown, NY

Play Ball! CooperstownStay.com has 4 bedroom rentals available for your big trip to Cooperstown, NY. You can choose to stay in a house close to Cooperstown Dreams Park or in nearby Oneonta, NY.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Private Homes / 4 Bedrooms

1825 Cottage

$2100 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.4 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
NEW RENOVATION - 1825 Cottage is a delightful combination of a vintage house frame combined with a contemporary open floor plan and furnishings.

Immaculate, well cared for 4 bedroom, 2 bath home with very large open well manicured field in the back.  Enjoy campfires by the scenic pond.  This home neighbors 1825 Farmhouse and 1825 Barn .
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

1825 Farmhouse

$2100 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.4 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
1825 Farmhouse is perfect choice for families who choose to be in a private setting with room to roam in the large well manicured meadow and fish in the pond and still be be close to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
Guests enjoy gathering and cooking together in the large kitchen / dining area.
This home neighbors 1825 Cottage and is near 1825 Barn .
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Alan's Corner

$2500 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
1.8 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
20 mi to All Star Village
Four bedroom home halfway between the Cooperstown Dreams Park and the Village of Cooperstown. Wood floors throughout. Above ground pool.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Amazing Valley

$3100 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6 mi to Dreams Park
13 mi to Baseball World
15 mi to All Star Village
Welcoming 4 bedroom home just minutes south of the Cooperstown Dreams Park with awesome view of the Susquehanna River valley and rolling hills. Spacious open decking overlooking above ground pool.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

At Home Base IV

$1795 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
0.5 mi to Dreams Park
15.8 mi to Baseball World
21.9 mi to All Star Village
The AT HOME BASE team features four private homes just a half mile from Cooperstown Dreams Park. This unit is a 4 bedroom / 2 bath home with a large open deck overlooking the spacious grounds with a view of the rolling hills beyond. Basketball hoop and basketball hoop included.

One well supervised team party welcome.

Companion units:
At Home Base I , At Home Base II, At Home Base III


Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Best Bet

$3100 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 4.5ba Sleeps 10
1.6 mi to Dreams Park
18.3 mi to Baseball World
17.8 mi to All Star Village
Airy, open contemporary floor plan.  Morning coffee on the deck greets the sunrise and the rolling hills. Dreams Park is less than a five minute drive. Separate quiet area for work, TV, or connecting your game console.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Blueberry Hill

$3100 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
4.7 mi to Dreams Park
25.2 mi to Baseball World
24.6 mi to All Star Village
Spectacular private setting with spacious lawns. Open and screened in decks. Hot tub overlooking front lawn.  Very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
One well supervised team party welcome.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Bridgecreek

Water Access Nearby
$2290 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
3.7 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
21 mi to All Star Village
Bridgecreek is very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams park and Village of Cooperstown. The 5 acre yard is bordered by Oaks Creek which is great for fishing. Very private, quiet setting. Sports equipment provided. Whole house water filtration.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Cottage House

$1490 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 7
8.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.4 mi to Baseball World
8 mi to All Star Village
Country home in serene country setting and beautiful views of the rolling hills. Inviting open rear deck for dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Creekside

$2500 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 3ba Sleeps 10
6.3 mi to Dreams Park
14.4 mi to Baseball World
13.1 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
Immaculate custom designed contemporary home overlooking scenic pond, large yard in private country setting. Enjoy the scenic pond or picnic by a small meandering stream at edge of property.

This home has 2 main living areas with 3 bedrooms / 2 baths on main level and a separate 1 bdrm / 1 bath apartment on the lower level. 

Guests especially enjoy the complete game room w/ pool, ping pong, air hockey, and shuffleboard.  The spacious yard has a fire pit! This pristine welcoming home has it all!
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Ingleside

$2060 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
0.6 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
21.7 mi to All Star Village
Two story home just a half mile from the Dreams Park gate.  This renovated home is in immaculate condition. Pleasant family oriented decor. Basketball hoop and fire pit.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Kenwood

$2800 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
1.4 mi to Dreams Park
20.8 mi to Baseball World
20.6 mi to All Star Village

Kenwood - a delightful combination of vintage architecture and contemporary decor and furnishings. This 4 bedroom home is very convenient to the Dreams Park and the village of Cooperstown. New ownership in fall of 2019.

A game room in a separate outbuilding has air hockey and ping pong.  There is a very large back yard for pick-up games.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Millburn House

Water Access Nearby
$2200 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
5 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
13.5 mi to All Star Village
Immaculate country home in private setting, conveniently located less than 10 minutes from the Cooperstown Dreams Park. Spacious grounds include a fire pit for family campfires under the stars. Car roof top boat launch just minutes down the road on Arnold Lake. Game room features an air hockey table.

Two covered porches and a balcony invite you to relax and visit awhile. 
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Pagey's Place

$1890 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
7.7 mi to Dreams Park
24 mi to Baseball World
31.2 mi to All Star Village
This immaculate 4 bdrm/2 bath  home was custom built by your host. It features a covered wrap-around porch with a commanding view of the lush valley and rolling hills beyond.

This home has an extraordinary 13+ year rental history thru another venue.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

The Lodge

Private Pond
$3600 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 8
8.7 mi to Dreams Park
12.1 mi to Baseball World
15.1 mi to All Star Village
The Lodge is a very unique offering with it's own 8 acre private lake.  Interior features vaulted ceiling of timbers in the great room and ceilings throughout. Large wrap-around covered porch, partially screened-in. Canoes, and fishing poles provided.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

The Shire

$2200 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 3ba Sleeps 8
3.8 mi to Dreams Park
15.7 mi to Baseball World
15.5 mi to All Star Village
Charming renovated 4 bedroom home with contemporary décor in Milford.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

Wake Robin Cottage

$2650 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 4.5ba Sleeps 9
10 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
12.3 mi to All Star Village
Unique 4 bedroom / 4 bath home. Spacious common areas - with open flow from living to dining area. One bedroom with bath en suite on first floor; remaining 3 bedrooms & baths on second floor.
Availability In 2022 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
5/29
to 6/4
6/4
to 6/10
6/10
to 6/16
6/16
to 6/22
6/22
to 6/28
6/28
to 7/4
7/4
to 7/10
7/10
to 7/16
7/16
to 7/22
7/22
to 7/28
7/28
to 8/3
8/3
to 8/9
8/9
to 8/15
8/15
to 8/21
8/21
to 8/27
8/27
to 9/2

128 Winney Hill

$2290 + tax
6 Nights
NO additional fees
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
18.2 mi to Dreams Park
3.2 mi to Baseball World
1 mi to All Star Village
For Help
Call 607-547-6260 or