Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos

    Lodge Exterior

  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound from the water Adirondack Waterfront Compound from the water
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound from the water
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound Adirondack Waterfront Compound
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound outside dining area Adirondack Waterfront Compound outside dining area
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound outside dining area
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound Adirondack Waterfront Compound
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound
  • Boathouse Exterior

  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound exterior
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound porch Adirondack Waterfront Compound porch
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound porch
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound yard Adirondack Waterfront Compound yard
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound yard

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Adirondack Waterfront Compound

Goodyear Lake
$6200/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
8br 4ba Sleeps 16
11 mi to Dreams Park
8.8 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
2282 State Route 28
Oneonta NY 13820
GPS: 42.50409, -74.98592
GOODYEAR LAKE - Adirondack Waterfront Compound a multi-family compound that sits on a 2-acre wooded lot on the western shore of Goodyear Lake. Built in 1901, this historic property consists of a 3-story main house and adjacent boathouse cottage. It is a perfect choice for large groups; there is room for everyone inside and out. There 8 bedrooms, 5 with lake views, and 4 full baths and an outdoor shower.

Lighted wooden steps show the way from the driveway  to each house and the private 200' waterfront. In addition to 2 canoes, outdoor amenities include extensive waterfront decking, Adirondack-style seating and a fire pit. An outdoor dining area is complete with stone fireplace grill and an oversized dining table. A large flat lawn area set up for either volleyball or soccer, complete with goals.

This property is convenient to baseball tournaments in both Cooperstown and Oneonta.

Wireless internet access throughout.

LODGE

The main level is open-concept with living room, kitchen and a screened-in sleeping porch that spans the width of the house showcasing breathtaking views of the lake. The lower level is a lakefront walk-out and is set up as a game room, bathroom and laundry room. The bedrooms are all located on the upper level and are set up as three 2-bedroom suites; each queen room overlooks the lake. Each level has its own recently renovated full bathroom with in-floor heating for those cool mornings. There are hardwood floors throughout.

Main Floor: Updates in 2016 include zoned AC in the great room, slate floors, a stainless apron farmhouse sink, open shelving, new wood counter tops and a gas stove in the kitchen. The décor is a pleasant blend of modern amenities and rustic antiques. The great room is highlighted by original “lawyer’s oak paneling”, an oversized, custom-designed farmhouse table, 2 seating areas, 42” flat screen TV with DVD player along with the original brick fireplace.

Upper Level: Offers 6 bedrooms set up as three separate suites.  Each suite has a twin bedroom with closet and adjoining queen bedroom which overlooks the lake. There are 2 TVs and 2 ceiling fans in each suite. For your added comfort, each suite also has newly installed zoned AC.

Lower Level: This level includes the game room and laundry room. It is surrounded by windows and opens directly to the waterfront. The newly renovated game room is complete with a second gas fireplace, bar seating with an extra refrigerator, flat-screen TV/DVD, foosball, air hockey, board games and books, etc., as well as lounge seating.

BOATHOUSE

The Boathouse cottage is adjacent to the Lodge, separated only by a gate. With its over-the- lake woodland setting, it offers the most private of accommodations within the compound. The cottage consists of 2 bedrooms, one with a king bed and the other with 2 queen beds, full bathroom with tub, kitchen with newer appliances including a dishwasher and washer/dryer, a comfortable living room, dining room, and a private screened-in porch. The décor is a mix of leather and antiques. It has hardwood floors throughout, plus 3 flat-screen TVs and a DVD player.

Amenities for both houses:
  • 200 ft private waterfront
  • Extensive outdoor decking with new waterfront seating &   dining
  • Two outdoor gas grills plus stone fireplace grill
  • 2 docks with space to tie up a boat
  • Ceiling fans in all bedrooms
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • 2 canoes
  • Life jackets in all sizes
  • Volleyball and soccer field
  • Basketball hoop
  • Bed linens provided
  • Towels provided
  • Hair dryer in each house
  • Iron + ironing board in each house
  • Generally good cell service

LODGE
(Sleeps 9)

•6 Bedrooms, arranged as three 2-bedroom suites each with 2 flat-screen TVs, 2 ceiling fans and zoned AC.

Suite 1
1st Bedroom – 1 queen with adjustable Temperpedic bed
2nd Bedroom – 1 twin

Suite 2
3rd Bedroom – 1 queen
4th Bedroom – 1 twin

Suite 3
5th Bedroom – 1 queen
6th Bedroom – 1 twin

3 Baths – one on each level, 2 with shower and 1 with claw-foot tub and stylized sink, in-floor heating

  • 4-Zone AC (living area + each suite)
  • Open concept great room with lake view, 2 sitting areas, large dining table, gas fireplace,42” flat-screen TV
  • Large, screened in sleeping porch overlooks lake with double bed and oversized seating
  • 2 gas fireplaces
  • Laundry room with washer/dryer
  • 8 flat-screen TVs
  • DVD players in living room and game room
  • Kitchen with gas stove, newer refrigerator and dishwasher; farmhouse sink (kitchen is fully stocked)
  • Game room with second refrigerator, foosball, air hockey, TV w/DVD player, bar seating, gas fireplace
  • 3535 square feet
BOATHOUSE (Sleeps 6-7)
  • 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 6 - 7
    All on one Floor
    1st Bedroom – 1 king
    2nd Bedroom – 2 queens
    Roll-away Bed
  • 1 bathroom with tub/shower combo
  • Outdoor shower
  • Wireless Internet
  • AC and ceiling fans throughout
  • 3 TVs/cable/DVD, incl large flat screen
  • Washer/Dryer
  • Living room
  • Dining room
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher (kitchen is fully stocked)
  • Screened-in porch w/ lake view
  • Small private yard, picnic tale & fire pit
  • 1200 square feet
  • 11 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 16.1 miles to Cooperstown
  • 8 miles to Oneonta
  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or larger gatherings.
  •  Maximum capacity:  16 people (9 in Lodge and 7 in Boathouse)

  • Rates: Summer weekly - whole compound -$6200 + tax
    Refundable damage/security deposit - $500

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Adirondack Waterfront Compound
5 Stars!
Amber from VA - 8/16/2019

This house had everything we needed for our group of families. The kids had fun fishing and swimming in the lake. Short drive to restaurants and downtown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 7/12/2019

We have stayed twice! Great swimming, boating and fishing. Lots of room with nice amenities.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kim B from FL - 7/5/2019

For families with kids playing at Cooperstown this is a perfect location! The 4 families that stayed at this property really enjoyed themselves and our boys were able to come enjoy the lake for a little downtime away from the barracks, even though they didn’t want to leave very often. The owners of this property were very helpful with any questions we had during our stay. Highly recommend!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kristi from MI - 6/28/2019

This facility is a great escape. We were there for Cooperstown and we merged 5 families. It was close enough to the fields to come home in between games (13ish minutes). The fishing was great and the kids enjoyed swimming. The accommodations were comfortable! I would highly recommend!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lindsay from LA - 6/21/2019

The house was absolutely perfect! Beautiful views, lots of space. Everything we needed!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Trish T from TN - 6/15/2018

Location is great, beautiful lake front setting and very spacious.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from CT - 8/18/2017
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tracy R from GA - 6/9/2017

Lots of room; beautiful scenery; close to baseball

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

GOODYEAR LAKE - Adirondack Waterfront Compound a multi-family compound that sits on a 2-acre wooded lot on the western shore of Goodyear Lake. Built in 1901, this historic property consists of a 3-story main house and adjacent boathouse cottage. It is a perfect choice for large groups; there is room for everyone inside and out. There 8 bedrooms, 5 with lake views, and 4 full baths and an outdoor shower.

Lighted wooden steps show the way from the driveway  to each house and the private 200' waterfront. In addition to 2 canoes, outdoor amenities include extensive waterfront decking, Adirondack-style seating and a fire pit. An outdoor dining area is complete with stone fireplace grill and an oversized dining table. A large flat lawn area set up for either volleyball or soccer, complete with goals.

This property is convenient to baseball tournaments in both Cooperstown and Oneonta.

Wireless internet access throughout.

LODGE

The main level is open-concept with living room, kitchen and a screened-in sleeping porch that spans the width of the house showcasing breathtaking views of the lake. The lower level is a lakefront walk-out and is set up as a game room, bathroom and laundry room. The bedrooms are all located on the upper level and are set up as three 2-bedroom suites; each queen room overlooks the lake. Each level has its own recently renovated full bathroom with in-floor heating for those cool mornings. There are hardwood floors throughout.

Main Floor: Updates in 2016 include zoned AC in the great room, slate floors, a stainless apron farmhouse sink, open shelving, new wood counter tops and a gas stove in the kitchen. The décor is a pleasant blend of modern amenities and rustic antiques. The great room is highlighted by original “lawyer’s oak paneling”, an oversized, custom-designed farmhouse table, 2 seating areas, 42” flat screen TV with DVD player along with the original brick fireplace.

Upper Level: Offers 6 bedrooms set up as three separate suites.  Each suite has a twin bedroom with closet and adjoining queen bedroom which overlooks the lake. There are 2 TVs and 2 ceiling fans in each suite. For your added comfort, each suite also has newly installed zoned AC.

Lower Level: This level includes the game room and laundry room. It is surrounded by windows and opens directly to the waterfront. The newly renovated game room is complete with a second gas fireplace, bar seating with an extra refrigerator, flat-screen TV/DVD, foosball, air hockey, board games and books, etc., as well as lounge seating.

BOATHOUSE

The Boathouse cottage is adjacent to the Lodge, separated only by a gate. With its over-the- lake woodland setting, it offers the most private of accommodations within the compound. The cottage consists of 2 bedrooms, one with a king bed and the other with 2 queen beds, full bathroom with tub, kitchen with newer appliances including a dishwasher and washer/dryer, a comfortable living room, dining room, and a private screened-in porch. The décor is a mix of leather and antiques. It has hardwood floors throughout, plus 3 flat-screen TVs and a DVD player.

Amenities for both houses:
  • 200 ft private waterfront
  • Extensive outdoor decking with new waterfront seating &   dining
  • Two outdoor gas grills plus stone fireplace grill
  • 2 docks with space to tie up a boat
  • Ceiling fans in all bedrooms
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • 2 canoes
  • Life jackets in all sizes
  • Volleyball and soccer field
  • Basketball hoop
  • Bed linens provided
  • Towels provided
  • Hair dryer in each house
  • Iron + ironing board in each house
  • Generally good cell service

LODGE
(Sleeps 9)

•6 Bedrooms, arranged as three 2-bedroom suites each with 2 flat-screen TVs, 2 ceiling fans and zoned AC.

Suite 1
1st Bedroom – 1 queen with adjustable Temperpedic bed
2nd Bedroom – 1 twin

Suite 2
3rd Bedroom – 1 queen
4th Bedroom – 1 twin

Suite 3
5th Bedroom – 1 queen
6th Bedroom – 1 twin

3 Baths – one on each level, 2 with shower and 1 with claw-foot tub and stylized sink, in-floor heating

  • 4-Zone AC (living area + each suite)
  • Open concept great room with lake view, 2 sitting areas, large dining table, gas fireplace,42” flat-screen TV
  • Large, screened in sleeping porch overlooks lake with double bed and oversized seating
  • 2 gas fireplaces
  • Laundry room with washer/dryer
  • 8 flat-screen TVs
  • DVD players in living room and game room
  • Kitchen with gas stove, newer refrigerator and dishwasher; farmhouse sink (kitchen is fully stocked)
  • Game room with second refrigerator, foosball, air hockey, TV w/DVD player, bar seating, gas fireplace
  • 3535 square feet
BOATHOUSE (Sleeps 6-7)
  • 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 6 - 7
    All on one Floor
    1st Bedroom – 1 king
    2nd Bedroom – 2 queens
    Roll-away Bed
  • 1 bathroom with tub/shower combo
  • Outdoor shower
  • Wireless Internet
  • AC and ceiling fans throughout
  • 3 TVs/cable/DVD, incl large flat screen
  • Washer/Dryer
  • Living room
  • Dining room
  • Kitchen w/ dishwasher (kitchen is fully stocked)
  • Screened-in porch w/ lake view
  • Small private yard, picnic tale & fire pit
  • 1200 square feet
  • 11 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 16.1 miles to Cooperstown
  • 8 miles to Oneonta
  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or larger gatherings.
  •  Maximum capacity:  16 people (9 in Lodge and 7 in Boathouse)

  • Rates: Summer weekly - whole compound -$6200 + tax
    Refundable damage/security deposit - $500

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Adirondack Waterfront Compound
5 Stars!
Amber from VA - 8/16/2019

This house had everything we needed for our group of families. The kids had fun fishing and swimming in the lake. Short drive to restaurants and downtown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 7/12/2019

We have stayed twice! Great swimming, boating and fishing. Lots of room with nice amenities.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kim B from FL - 7/5/2019

For families with kids playing at Cooperstown this is a perfect location! The 4 families that stayed at this property really enjoyed themselves and our boys were able to come enjoy the lake for a little downtime away from the barracks, even though they didn’t want to leave very often. The owners of this property were very helpful with any questions we had during our stay. Highly recommend!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kristi from MI - 6/28/2019

This facility is a great escape. We were there for Cooperstown and we merged 5 families. It was close enough to the fields to come home in between games (13ish minutes). The fishing was great and the kids enjoyed swimming. The accommodations were comfortable! I would highly recommend!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lindsay from LA - 6/21/2019

The house was absolutely perfect! Beautiful views, lots of space. Everything we needed!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Trish T from TN - 6/15/2018

Location is great, beautiful lake front setting and very spacious.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from CT - 8/18/2017
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tracy R from GA - 6/9/2017

Lots of room; beautiful scenery; close to baseball

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos

    Lodge Interior

  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound Adirondack Waterfront Compound
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound great room Adirondack Waterfront Compound great room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound great room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound dining area Adirondack Waterfront Compound dining area
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound dining area
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound TV Adirondack Waterfront Compound TV
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound TV
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound Adirondack Waterfront Compound
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound Adirondack Waterfront Compound
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound sunroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
  • Boathouse Interior

  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound living room
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound kitchen
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bedroom
  • Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath
    Adirondack Waterfront Compound bath