Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos
  • Garth Newell exterior Garth Newell exterior
    Garth Newell exterior
  • Garth Newell deck Garth Newell deck
    Garth Newell deck
  • Garth Newell patio Garth Newell patio
    Garth Newell patio
  • Garth Newell hammock Garth Newell hammock
    Garth Newell hammock
  • Garth Newell waterfront Garth Newell waterfront
    Garth Newell waterfront
  • Garth Newell dock Garth Newell dock
    Garth Newell dock
  • Garth Newell waterfront Garth Newell waterfront
    Garth Newell waterfront
  • Garth Newell waterfront Garth Newell waterfront
    Garth Newell waterfront

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Garth Newell

Goodyear Lake
$2200/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.8 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
181 Lake Shore Drive South
Maryland NY 12116
GPS: 42.51053, -74.98433
GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2010, Garth Newel means New House in Welsh.This private apartment is located on the lower level of the owner's home.  Garth Newell guests enjoy a stone patio with rocking chairs, a deck with picnic table  and a fire pit on the lawn - all overlooking the 135 foot waterfront.  There is a private entrance and a dock for swimming and fishing.  The owner provides three tandem kayaks, a stand up paddle board, and fishing gear for your pleasure. A hammock provides relaxation. 

The delightful décor is complete with a gas burning fireplace in the living area.  The spacious main room includes a kitchen and living area.  There is a separate dining area.

Note:  Owner has 4 outside cats in residence.  They are not allowed in the apartment, but you may see them on the grounds.

Wireless internet access.

Amenities:
  • 2 bedrooms, sleeps 6
  • All on lower level
    1st Bedroom – 2 queens
    2nd Bedroom – 1 queen + 1 double
  • 1 Bath w/ tub/shower
  • Wireless internet access
  • A/C units in main living area + large bedroom
  • Washer/dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 3 TVs/satellite/DVD - Blue Ray, incl. a 42” flat screen
  • Phone – unlimited service (no international calls) 
  • Generally good cell service
  • Kitchen area
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Deck with picnic table
  • Outdoor seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Fire pit
  • Water trampoline
  • 3 kayaks, 1 canoe, 1 Stand-up paddle board
  • Life jackets
  • Fishing + fishing gear
  • Swimming
  • Croquet set
  • Dock
  • 1200 square feet
     
  • 10.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.6 miles to Cooperstown
  • 9.8 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.4 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings
     
  • Maximum capacity:  6 people
     
  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2200+ tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Garth Newell
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 7/12/2019

The property was clean, well maintained and had a perfect view of the lake. Also, having all of the amenities available for kayaking, fishing, etc. made it very nice. They also had tons of towels, life jackets, etc. and we really appreciated the hosts hospitality.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Renee from LA - 7/5/2019

This place is wonderful. The inside is very nice, clean and comfortable, but the real gem is the outside. The view of the lake is beautiful. Garth Newell provided everything we needed like kayaks, fishing poles, water trampoline and many more. The kids and adults had a blast. The guys caught SO many fish. The fire pit was a cozy area. It was great!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 8/17/2018

Lovely setting, kayaks available, a home away from home.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Michelle B from PA - 7/27/2018

Paul and Ann were so accommodating. The house was stocked with everything promised and more! The property is beautiful inside and out and most importantly it was clean. Our kids loved the lake and all the water equipment available to them. From fishing to paddle boarding to jumping on the water trampoline there was hours of fun to be had. The grownups enjoyed sitting by the fire pit and relaxing outside between baseball games while watching the kids in the lake! It was so nice to come to a house with linens on the beds and towels ready for the shower. Highly recommended! Thank you Paul and Ann!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from OH - 7/13/2018

Property beautiful, comfortable, hosts were great.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from FL - 6/29/2018

Garth Newell property was absolutely perfect for our week in Cooperstown. The home was very clean and had the essentials needed. My family fished, paddle boarded, kayaked, jumped on the water trampoline, relaxed in the hammock, and enjoyed the overall beautiful lake view. We highly recommend this property!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from UT - 6/8/2018

We loved staying at Garth Newell. The property was beautiful and in perfect condition. The owners Ann and Paul were so welcoming, kind, helpful and attentive to anything we needed. We loved spending time on the lake! We would definitely recommend this property to anyone!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from FL - 6/1/2018
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Bob C from CA - 7/21/2017

Exceeded my expectations for size, cleanliness, amenities, location and owners. Anything needed the owners where more than willing to help with. Great spot for my family to stay while my son played baseball!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 6/23/2017

The property is absolutely beautiful and comes with kayaks, paddle board, canoe, fishing equipment. The house comes with all of the necessary amenities so all you need to bring are your clothes. In addition, it is perfectly located between Dreams Park and Oneonta. Paul and Ann are great owners!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from GA - 6/16/2017

Great place to relax before or after baseball.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Shadi Z from MA - 8/5/2016

The house was spacious, cozy, very clean. The view of the lake was very serene. We loved the kayaks and the trampoline. The dock was very nice. The house had EVERYTHING we could need. Well stocked. All we needed to shop for were the groceries and drinks for us and the kids.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kent H from TX - 6/10/2016

Paul and Ann were terrific hosts and the property is beautiful. Easy drive to both All-Star Village and Dreams Park. Now we just need to adopt a 12 year old baseball player so we can go back!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from IL - 6/3/2016

Great accommodations; very clean; everything you would need there; wonderful owners (even came to my son's game); they communicated a few times prior to our visit and on the day we arrived that helped make check in very easy. Just all around great stay.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Garth N from NJ - 8/14/2015

Having lived in Florida and spent my summers in the northeast for 15 years, I have tons of rental experience. This place exceeded expectations in every way, and provided everything you need down to the last detail.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Debbie from FL - 7/17/2015

Owners were wonderful. Unit was immaculately clean. Location was superb and had something for everyone. From relaxation in the hammock to entertaining on the deck to fun in the water. I would definitely stay there again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Alysia C from MD - 7/10/2015

The owners are very nice. The house is wonderful and the view is spectacular.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
william l from MD - 7/3/2015

accommodations were great. high attention to detail in every regard. lake was amazing. ann and paul were fantastic.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Joanne H from PA - 6/12/2015

Beautiful location. Ann and Paul were very welcoming, attentive to our needs and even came to Cooperstown games to cheer on our son!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2010, Garth Newel means New House in Welsh.This private apartment is located on the lower level of the owner's home.  Garth Newell guests enjoy a stone patio with rocking chairs, a deck with picnic table  and a fire pit on the lawn - all overlooking the 135 foot waterfront.  There is a private entrance and a dock for swimming and fishing.  The owner provides three tandem kayaks, a stand up paddle board, and fishing gear for your pleasure. A hammock provides relaxation. 

The delightful décor is complete with a gas burning fireplace in the living area.  The spacious main room includes a kitchen and living area.  There is a separate dining area.

Note:  Owner has 4 outside cats in residence.  They are not allowed in the apartment, but you may see them on the grounds.

Wireless internet access.

Amenities:
  • 2 bedrooms, sleeps 6
  • All on lower level
    1st Bedroom – 2 queens
    2nd Bedroom – 1 queen + 1 double
  • 1 Bath w/ tub/shower
  • Wireless internet access
  • A/C units in main living area + large bedroom
  • Washer/dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens + towels provided
  • 3 TVs/satellite/DVD - Blue Ray, incl. a 42” flat screen
  • Phone – unlimited service (no international calls) 
  • Generally good cell service
  • Kitchen area
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Deck with picnic table
  • Outdoor seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Fire pit
  • Water trampoline
  • 3 kayaks, 1 canoe, 1 Stand-up paddle board
  • Life jackets
  • Fishing + fishing gear
  • Swimming
  • Croquet set
  • Dock
  • 1200 square feet
     
  • 10.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.6 miles to Cooperstown
  • 9.8 miles to Baseball World
  • 12.4 miles to All Star Village

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings
     
  • Maximum capacity:  6 people
     
  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2200+ tax
    Refundable damage deposit:  $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Garth Newell
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 7/12/2019

The property was clean, well maintained and had a perfect view of the lake. Also, having all of the amenities available for kayaking, fishing, etc. made it very nice. They also had tons of towels, life jackets, etc. and we really appreciated the hosts hospitality.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Renee from LA - 7/5/2019

This place is wonderful. The inside is very nice, clean and comfortable, but the real gem is the outside. The view of the lake is beautiful. Garth Newell provided everything we needed like kayaks, fishing poles, water trampoline and many more. The kids and adults had a blast. The guys caught SO many fish. The fire pit was a cozy area. It was great!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 8/17/2018

Lovely setting, kayaks available, a home away from home.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Michelle B from PA - 7/27/2018

Paul and Ann were so accommodating. The house was stocked with everything promised and more! The property is beautiful inside and out and most importantly it was clean. Our kids loved the lake and all the water equipment available to them. From fishing to paddle boarding to jumping on the water trampoline there was hours of fun to be had. The grownups enjoyed sitting by the fire pit and relaxing outside between baseball games while watching the kids in the lake! It was so nice to come to a house with linens on the beds and towels ready for the shower. Highly recommended! Thank you Paul and Ann!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from OH - 7/13/2018

Property beautiful, comfortable, hosts were great.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from FL - 6/29/2018

Garth Newell property was absolutely perfect for our week in Cooperstown. The home was very clean and had the essentials needed. My family fished, paddle boarded, kayaked, jumped on the water trampoline, relaxed in the hammock, and enjoyed the overall beautiful lake view. We highly recommend this property!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from UT - 6/8/2018

We loved staying at Garth Newell. The property was beautiful and in perfect condition. The owners Ann and Paul were so welcoming, kind, helpful and attentive to anything we needed. We loved spending time on the lake! We would definitely recommend this property to anyone!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from FL - 6/1/2018
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Bob C from CA - 7/21/2017

Exceeded my expectations for size, cleanliness, amenities, location and owners. Anything needed the owners where more than willing to help with. Great spot for my family to stay while my son played baseball!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MD - 6/23/2017

The property is absolutely beautiful and comes with kayaks, paddle board, canoe, fishing equipment. The house comes with all of the necessary amenities so all you need to bring are your clothes. In addition, it is perfectly located between Dreams Park and Oneonta. Paul and Ann are great owners!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from GA - 6/16/2017

Great place to relax before or after baseball.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Shadi Z from MA - 8/5/2016

The house was spacious, cozy, very clean. The view of the lake was very serene. We loved the kayaks and the trampoline. The dock was very nice. The house had EVERYTHING we could need. Well stocked. All we needed to shop for were the groceries and drinks for us and the kids.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kent H from TX - 6/10/2016

Paul and Ann were terrific hosts and the property is beautiful. Easy drive to both All-Star Village and Dreams Park. Now we just need to adopt a 12 year old baseball player so we can go back!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from IL - 6/3/2016

Great accommodations; very clean; everything you would need there; wonderful owners (even came to my son's game); they communicated a few times prior to our visit and on the day we arrived that helped make check in very easy. Just all around great stay.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Garth N from NJ - 8/14/2015

Having lived in Florida and spent my summers in the northeast for 15 years, I have tons of rental experience. This place exceeded expectations in every way, and provided everything you need down to the last detail.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Debbie from FL - 7/17/2015

Owners were wonderful. Unit was immaculately clean. Location was superb and had something for everyone. From relaxation in the hammock to entertaining on the deck to fun in the water. I would definitely stay there again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Alysia C from MD - 7/10/2015

The owners are very nice. The house is wonderful and the view is spectacular.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
william l from MD - 7/3/2015

accommodations were great. high attention to detail in every regard. lake was amazing. ann and paul were fantastic.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Joanne H from PA - 6/12/2015

Beautiful location. Ann and Paul were very welcoming, attentive to our needs and even came to Cooperstown games to cheer on our son!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos
  • Garth Newell living room Garth Newell living room
    Garth Newell living room
  • Garth Newell fireplace Garth Newell fireplace
    Garth Newell fireplace
  • Garth Newell dining room Garth Newell dining room
    Garth Newell dining room
  • Garth Newell kitchen Garth Newell kitchen
    Garth Newell kitchen
  • Garth Newell bedroom Garth Newell bedroom
    Garth Newell bedroom
  • Garth Newell bedroom Garth Newell bedroom
    Garth Newell bedroom
  • Garth Newell bath Garth Newell bath
    Garth Newell bath