Rental Apartments in Cooperstown NY

Looking for economical weekly rentals in Cooperstown, NY? We have apartment rentals available for families coming to Cooperstown to play a tournament at the Dreams Park. Visit CooperstownStay.com or call 607-547-6260 for personal assistance.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter any/part of the property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • - Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • - Bath towels
  • - Television with Cable or Satellite
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities are included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!


Note:
  1. 1.  Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host.
  2. 2. Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless it is specifically listed.
  3. 3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Apartments

1880 Schoolhouse

$1700/week
2br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
26.1 mi to Baseball World
23.8 mi to All Star Village
1880 Schoolhouse - located in quiet hamlet of Fly Creek, just 5 minutes from Cooperstown and 10 minutes from the Dreams Park. Large yard with swing set.  An outdoor open fire place provides enjoyment for whole family.  Part of a recently renovated duplex. Charming, welcoming, spacious 1750 sq ft.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

2 Pine

$920-1385/wk
1-3br 1-2ba Sleeps 4-8
5 mi to Dreams Park
23 mi to Baseball World
25 mi to All Star Village
Formerly known as Aida's Place. Gracious Victorian home with five separate apartments.  Located in the village of Cooperstown on a quiet residential street. Off street parking. Very close to Main Street shops, restaurants and National Baseball Hall of Fame.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
2 Pine Apt # 1
2 Pine Apt # 2
2 Pine Apt # 4
2 Pine Apt # 5
2 Pine Apt # 7

20 Glengrove Place

$1990/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
4.7 mi to Dreams Park
24.5 mi to Baseball World
23.5 mi to All Star Village
Charming apartment in village of Cooperstown, just one half block to Main Street.  Covered, screened porch overlooking yard. Basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

42 North Apartment

$1370/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 2
13.2 mi to Dreams Park
24 mi to Baseball World
25.1 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2014. Upscale 1 bedroom apartment w/ tasteful decor in private country setting.Delightful rear deck for outdoor dining and and seating. Check out 42 North on the same property.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Agaseto

$1765/week
2br 1.5ba Sleeps 5
4.6 mi to Dreams Park
24.3 mi to Baseball World
23.3 mi to All Star Village
Charming and inviting mix of vintage Victorian and modern amenities, this two bedroom apartment is located in the heart of Cooperstown just 3 blocks from Main Street shops and restaurants and less than 10 minute drive to the Cooperstown Dreams Park.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

All Aboard

$1450-1550/wk
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
4.6 mi to Dreams Park
17.4 mi to Baseball World
18.1 mi to All Star Village
Stylish apartments, in exquisite condition just 1 block from Main Street, Cooperstown.  Classic Victorian home with quality, classic / contemporary renovation in 2008. Guests rave about the interiors! Modern amenities.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
All Aboard One
All Aboard Two

American Story Book

$835-900/wk
1br 1ba Sleeps 3-4
4 mi to Dreams Park
23 mi to Baseball World
25 mi to All Star Village
Charming, well maintained apartments in Cooperstown, convenient to Main Street shops & restaurants.  Off-street parking.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
American Story Book Apt 1
American Story Book Apt 3
American Story Book Apt 4
American Story Book Apt 5

Amish Barn

$950/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 4
6.8 mi to Dreams Park
19.3 mi to Baseball World
18.7 mi to All Star Village
Amish Barn Apartments are kept in immaculate condition. Awesome view, private location. Apartments located on 2nd floor - each with a private entrance and private balcony. The two units share a game room on the first floor.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Amish Barn One
Amish Barn Two

Apple Tree

$870-920/wk
1br 1ba Sleeps 4-5
3.7 mi to Dreams Park
15.7 mi to Baseball World
15.4 mi to All Star Village
Two apartments in village setting in Milford, very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams Park. Outdoor dining area in rear yard. These apartments are kept in immaculate condition. 
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Apple Tree - Apt 1
Apple Tree - Apt 2

Bavarian Farm Apt

$1050/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
9.5 mi to Dreams Park
28.9 mi to Baseball World
28.7 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2006, with Central A/C, awesome view, private patio.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bavarian Farm Studio

$950/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
9.5 mi to Dreams Park
28.9 mi to Baseball World
28.7 mi to All Star Village
Completed in 2002, a well designed studio apartment with an awesome view of Red Creek Valley.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bella Casa

$990-1030/wk
1br 1ba Sleeps 6-7
4.9 mi to Dreams Park
24.3 mi to Baseball World
23.2 mi to All Star Village
Three apartments in the heart of Cooperstown. New construction in rehabbed historic building 2004.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Bella Casa Apt 2
Bella Casa Apt 3
Bella Casa Apt 4

Briarwood

$840-1470/wk
1-2br 1-2ba Sleeps 3-6
6.1 mi to Dreams Park
17 mi to Baseball World
16.4 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
Built in 2003.  Delightful decor, less than 10 minutes to Dreams Park.  Two apartments are an ideal choice for those who wish to have private space, but be near each other.
Briarwood One is wheelchair accessible.

Briarwood One - located on 1st & 2nd floors
• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 6
• 2 Baths
• Summer weekly - $1470 + tax

Briarwood Two - lower level
• 1 Bedroom, sleeps 3
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $840 + tax

• 6.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
• 7.6 miles to Cooperstown
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Briarwood One
Briarwood Two

Creamery Apartments

$850-1400/wk
1-2br 1ba Sleeps 2-6
4.5 mi to Dreams Park
24.1 mi to Baseball World
23.1 mi to All Star Village
Recently renovated apartments, in Village of Cooperstown, convenient to shops, restaurants and the Cooperstown Dreams Park. Very tasteful decor that combines classic elements with contemporary flair.


Creamery Apartment # 1 - Second Floor

• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 4 - 6
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1200 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 2 - Second Floor
• 1 Bedroom, sleeps 2 - 4
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1100 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 3 - First Floor
• 1 Bedroom, sleeps 2 - 4
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1050 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 4 - First Floor
• Studio, sleeps 2
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $850 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 5 - First Floor
• 1 Bedroom, sleeps 2 - 4
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1100 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 6 - Second Floor

• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 4 - 6
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1400 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 7 - First Floor
• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 4 - 6
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1300 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 8 - First Floor
• Studio, sleeps 2
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $900 + tax

Creamery Apartment # 9 - First Floor
• Studio, sleeps 2
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $900 + tax

• 4.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
• In Village of Cooperstown

Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Creamery Apartment # 1
Creamery Apartment # 2
Creamery Apartment # 3
Creamery Apartment # 4
Creamery Apartment # 5
Creamery Apartment # 6
Creamery Apartment # 7
Creamery Apartment # 8
Creamery Apartment # 9

Dandy-Li Inn Apartment

$1095/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
0.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.5 mi to Baseball World
20.4 mi to All Star Village
Contemporary apartment with bold contemporary decor. Open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, private entrance and private balcony overlooking back yard. Check out Dandy Li Inn a separate rental unit in the front of the building.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Deer Meadow Farm

$990/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
7.9 mi to Dreams Park
20.7 mi to Baseball World
21.4 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2005, awesome view, private location. Immaculate condition. Stylish décor. Deer Meadow Farm Studio is located on the same property.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Donnybrook

$720-1080/wk
1-2br 1-2ba Sleeps 4-5
8.8 mi to Dreams Park
22.3 mi to Baseball World
21.7 mi to All Star Village
Two spacious apartments in a side by side duplex. Country setting with large back yard. Ideal choice for families who wish to be near each other but still have private lodging.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Donnybrook North Apt.
Donnybrook South Apt.

Evergreen

$780/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
9.5 mi to Dreams Park
20.8 mi to Baseball World
21.2 mi to All Star Village
Peaceful and very private location with beautiful valley views.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Farmhouse 33

$900/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 2
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
18.9 mi to Baseball World
18.8 mi to All Star Village
Built in 2014, contemporary decor in quiet country setting just 10 minutes from Dreams Park or Cooperstown Village. Private entrance.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Florence Cottage

$920/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 4
5 mi to Dreams Park
24.9 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
Located in the heart of the village of Cooperstown, just one block from the Baseball Hall of Fame.  Canoe & Kayak available for paddling on Otsego Lake. First floor location.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Gentle Hills Apt

$900/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
6.5 mi to Dreams Park
26.1 mi to Baseball World
23.9 mi to All Star Village
New construction - Very spacious rooms w/ stylish decor. Within 5 minutes of Cooperstown and within 10 minutes of Dreams park.  Basketball hoop and fire pit. Check out Gentle Hills for a 4 bedroom offering.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Hidden Valley Pond

$695-800/wk
1-2br 1ba Sleeps 4-5
11.4 mi to Dreams Park
21.6 mi to Baseball World
23.1 mi to All Star Village
Newly renovated apartments in a peaceful, private, country setting.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Hidden Valley Pond Apt 1
Hidden Valley Pond Apt 2

Kessler Apartment

$780/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
3 mi to Dreams Park
17.6 mi to Baseball World
15.1 mi to All Star Village
Country apartment with covered front porch very close to the Dreams Park.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Middlefield Hill Apartment

$800/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
12.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.3 mi to Baseball World
24.6 mi to All Star Village
Private rural setting. A private wing of another rental, Middlefield Hill.  Ideal choice for small group who wishes to be near another family but enjoy their own private living space. 2 private fishing ponds and fire pit.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Park View

$1550/week
2br 2ba Sleeps 4
0.4 mi to Dreams Park
20 mi to Baseball World
22 mi to All Star Village
Adjacent to the fields of the Dreams Park, this apartment is extremely convenient.  New construction in 2005, it is complete with contemporary amenities, open deck looking over the Dreams Park complex..
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

South Meadow

$1900/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 10
0 mi to Dreams Park
19.5 mi to Baseball World
19.4 mi to All Star Village
South Meadow - closest possible lodging to Dreams Park - on the adjacent property. Recently renovated.  Watch games from the lawn.  Basketball hoop.

South Meadow Unit 1,  First Floor Location
• 4 Bedrooms, sleeps 10
• 2.5 Baths
• Summer weekly - $1900 + tax

South Meadow Unit 3, First Floor Location
• 4 Bedrooms, sleeps 10
• 2.5 Baths
• Summer weekly - $1900 + tax

• 0 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
• 5 miles to Cooperstown
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
South Meadow Unit 1
South Meadow Unit 3

Sunnyside Apartments

$890-1000/wk
1br 1ba Sleeps 2-4
0.6 mi to Dreams Park
19.8 mi to Baseball World
19.6 mi to All Star Village
These apartments are one half mile from the Cooperstown Dreams Park. New in 2003. In ground pool(new in 2016)and large side lawn for baseball.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Sunnyside Apt 1
Sunnyside Apt 2
Sunnyside Apt 3

Susquehanna House

$1190/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
4.7 mi to Dreams Park
23 mi to Baseball World
24 mi to All Star Village
Located in the village of Cooperstown, less than 2 blocks from Main Street shops and restaurants.  Charming and welcoming apartment on second floor of a vintage Victorian home.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Vintage House

$990-1090/wk
2br 1ba Sleeps 5-6
3.5 mi to Dreams Park
23.6 mi to Baseball World
20.7 mi to All Star Village
Vintage House is a delightful combination of early architecture with contemporary kitchens and baths.  It is located in the quiet residential of Toddsville just outside of Cooperstown and very convenient to the Dreams Park.

Vintage House One - First Floor Location
• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 6
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $1090 + tax

Vintage House Two - Second Floor Location
• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 4 - 5
• 1 Bath
• Summer weekly - $990 + tax

• 3.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
• 3.7 miles to Cooperstown
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Vintage House One
Vintage House Two

Wheelhouse Studio

$825/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
6.6 mi to Dreams Park
26.1 mi to Baseball World
24.3 mi to All Star Village
Built in 2006, studio apartment looking out over deck and spacious yard with view of valley and rolling hills.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Whitehill Cottage

$850/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 4
9.5 mi to Dreams Park
28.7 mi to Baseball World
28.5 mi to All Star Village
Charming, comfortable lodging in inviting country setting just north of Cooperstown. Second floor location.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Backstop Apartment

$1300/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
21 mi to Dreams Park
3.7 mi to Baseball World
1.9 mi to All Star Village
Ideal choice for All Star Village tournament families, less than a 5 minute drive to the fields. Private apartment on hill with awesome view of the Oneonta hills.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sunset Waters

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.6 mi to Baseball World
12.1 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Spacious 3 bedroom waterfront with beautiful sunset views from the patio and from the inside.  Private hot tub, canoe and fishing poles included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST