Cooperstown NY House Rentals on Lake, River or Water Access

Find weekly house rentals on the lake in Cooperstown, NY. We've got beautiful waterfront homes for rent - on the river, on a lake or with a private pond. Find lakefront house rentals at CooperstownStay.com. Search online or call 607-547-6260 for personal assistance.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter any/part of the property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • - Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • - Bath towels
  • - Television with Cable or Satellite
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities are included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!


Note:
  1. 1.  Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host.
  2. 2. Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless it is specifically listed.
  3. 3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Waterfront


Bass Haven

Riverfront
$2100/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
7.9 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.3 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Renovated in 2004, 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath home with great fishing right off the dock on river just north Goodyear Lake. Wood and tile floors throughout.  Convenient to all baseball tournaments.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Beau Rivage

Riverfront
$4000/week
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
8.4 mi to Dreams Park
11.5 mi to Baseball World
14.1 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Riverfront home located on the Susquehanna River at the head of  Goodyear Lake.  Major renovation 2016-2017. Paddle boat and row boat included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Eagle River

Riverfront
$1350/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.5 mi to Baseball World
14.1 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Charming waterfront home right on the river.  Fishing is great right off the rear deck. Fishing pole included. Use of canoe, kayak or stand-up paddle board included.  Just 10 minutes south of Cooperstown Dreams Park.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Riverview

Riverfront
$2400/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.2 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Located at the headwaters of Goodyear Lake, riverfront home with in peaceful setting on knoll above Susquehanna River. Beautifully decorated, with an artist’s eye. Large asymmetrical deck over beautiful yard and gardens.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Water's Edge

Riverfront
$1890/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
8.3 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
14.2 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Located at headwaters of Goodyear Lake. Three bedroom / two bath home with large lawn, enclosed gazebo and large deck overlooking the river. Wireless internet and Central Air.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Winding River

Riverfront
$1990/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
4.8 mi to Dreams Park
17.4 mi to Baseball World
19.8 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Welcoming home perched on a gentle knoll above horseshoe bend in the river. Awesome sunset views over river valley.  Access to river for fishing and paddle sports.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

A Lakeview Paradise

Goodyear Lake
$3350/week
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.1 mi to Baseball World
11.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New construction. Immaculate, two story home with dramatic lakeview. Hot tub and Central A/C.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

A Water View

Goodyear Lake
$1100/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 4
9.8 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
13.3 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Graciously decorated 1 bedroom suite with private covered deck overlooking the lake.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Adirondack Waterfront Compound

Goodyear Lake
$6000/week
8br 4ba Sleeps 16
11 mi to Dreams Park
8.8 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Multi-family compound. FKA Amy's Goodyear Lodge & Amy's Boathouse The lodge has 6 bedrooms + 3 baths, Boathouse has 2 bedrooms, 1 bath. Private waterfront w/ 2 docks, 2 canoes. Game room in Lodge.  Great fishing and swimming.  Zoned A/C + window A/C units.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Anglewoods

Goodyear Lake
$3350/week
4br 3.5ba Sleeps 9
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Welcoming waterfront home ideal for family fun at the lake. New kitchen and baths in 2012. One bath is ADA accessible. Two single kayaks, fire pit  and foosball table included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Aviva's Lakehouse

Goodyear Lake
$2150/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
10.4 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Spend a week by the water in this well cared for summer home w/ contemporary decor.  Accessible waterfront great for fishing or launching a canoe or kayak.  Canoe and 2 kayaks included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Avonmora

Goodyear Lake
$3250/week
4br 5ba Sleeps 9
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE -New renovation in 2013, this waterfront home has easy access to the private waterfront. Firepit by the waterfront, open deck and enclosed sun room all overlooking the water. Kayak available.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Awesome View

Canadargo Lake
$1750/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
17.3 mi to Dreams Park
31.1 mi to Baseball World
30.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New construction in 2009, located at north end of the lake, with level yard, wrap- around porch. Row boat and paddle boat included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Barb's Lakeside

Goodyear Lake
$4000/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
13.2 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Barbara's Lakeside is a real gem, perched above the lake with a splendid view of the lake - the sunrise is awesome. Multiple areas for outside seating and dining. Game room, canoe and kayaks provided.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Beautiful Bay

Goodyear Lake
$1600/week
1br 1.5ba Sleeps 4
10.7 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New Construction in 2017. Awesome water view. Great fishing, swimming and paddle sports area. Kayak and basketball hoop included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Big Pines

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.3 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
9.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Ranch home with large yard, waterfront access with canoe & flat bottom boat.  Great for fishing.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Birch Cove

Goodyear Lake
$1550/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
9.7 mi to Baseball World
12.3 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Charming two bedroom cottage with awesome view and large level yard with basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Blue Heron

Goodyear Lake
$2850/week
5br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
7.4 mi to Dreams Park
11 mi to Baseball World
13 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Charming, welcoming, ideal for families. Spacious lawn on private peninsula with 600 feet of waterfront. Paddle boat and canoe included. One of area's best fishing areas.Convenient to baseball tournaments in Cooperstown and Oneonta.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bluewaters

Canadargo Lake
$2690/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
13.17 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
26.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New renovation 2017. Exquisite waterfront home with stylish contemporary decor. Breathtaking view from all 3 levels. The host includes 2 tandem kayaks and 1 stand-up paddleboard.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bonnie's Cove

Goodyear Lake
$1100/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
8.9 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Cozy cottage with large level lawn down to water, in family oriented area.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bronx Bungalow

Canadargo Lake
$1550/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
18.7 mi to Dreams Park
32.3 mi to Baseball World
31.8 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Located on northern shore with a commanding view of the length of the lake. Fire pit at lakeside. One-acre level yard. Great fishing! Two kayaks included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Camp Champion

Otsego Lake
$1890/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
23.4 mi to Baseball World
24 mi to All Star Village
OTSEGO LAKE - Charming 3 bedroom cottage on private lane with lake access on Otsego Lake directly in front of the cottage.  Beautiful lake view.  Air hockey table.  Kayak provided.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Camp Lake View

Otsego Lake
$2800/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
11.4 mi to Dreams Park
31.2 mi to Baseball World
30.2 mi to All Star Village
OTSEGO LAKE - recently renovated waterfront home with awesome lake view, multi-tiered deck system, open floor plan.  Paddle boat and 2 kayaks included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Castaway Cottage

Goodyear Lake
$2700/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Renovated in 2016. Conveniently located to all baseball tournaments. 100 feet of private waterfront. Patio overlooking the water is ideal for outdoor dining and relaxing. Outdoor fire pit provides campfire time for the whole family.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Cliffside

Goodyear Lake
$1350/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
10.7 mi to Dreams Park
9.3 mi to Baseball World
11.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Exquisite offering with 2 decks and picturesque lake view. 2 kayaks available.  Owner provides lake tours upon request.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Commissioner's Coop

Goodyear Lake
$2550/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Exquisite log cabin home of new construction with large wrap around deck  open floor plan and tasteful decor.  Perfect choice for the discerning traveler.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Country Breeze

Goodyear Lake
$1840/week
2br 2ba Sleeps 7
10 mi to Dreams Park
11 mi to Baseball World
13.6 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Inviting vacation home with covered porch, balcony and deck. New construction.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Decked Out

Canadargo Lake
$2500/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
15.5 mi to Dreams Park
29.4 mi to Baseball World
28.6 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Awesome waterfront home with beautiful panoramic lake view. Open, inviting floor plan. Includes 8 kayaks, 1 standup paddle board, hot tub and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Fisher's Landing

Canadargo Lake
$3100/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 11
13.1 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
27.3 mi to All Star Village

CANADARAGO LAKE - Fisher's Landing was remodeled in 2011 with contemporary kitchen and baths. Awesome views and waterfront make it an ideal family vacation choice.

Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

For Ease

Arnold Lake
$1690/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
13.9 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
ARNOLD LAKE - New construction in 2010. Spacious open floor plan. Large 650 square foot wrap around deck with magnificent long distance lake view. Row boat provided.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Friendship Lodge

Goodyear Lake
$4700/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.8 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE -Built in 2005, exquisite spacious waterfront home with large yard, covered porch and extensive waterfront docks and decks. Canoe included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Garth Newell

Goodyear Lake
$2000/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.8 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New construction in 2010, a 2 bedroom apartment. Sailboat, 3 kayaks,  canoe, 1 stand-up paddle board and water trampoline included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Grassy Waters

Goodyear Lake
$1400/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
10.4 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Immaculate inviting summer cottage with open deck and a sun room facing the water.  Located on a double lot w/ large side yard.  Convenient to all baseball tournament locations.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Great Catch Cabin

Goodyear Lake
$2050/week
1br 1.5ba Sleeps 6
10.4 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Exquisite waterfront log cabin built in 2002 - lakefront living at its best.  Hot  tub on deck overlooking water. Paddle boat included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Harriet's Hideaway

Goodyear Lake
$1400/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
8.9 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Charming waterfront cottage with large level lawn down to water and dock. Host provides 2 canoes and 2 kayaks.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Heron Landing

Canadargo Lake
$4000/week
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
16.5 mi to Dreams Park
30.1 mi to Baseball World
29.4 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New construction, luxurious large home w/430 feet of private waterfront and beautiful panoramic views. Game room in separate building + basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Hidden Treasure

Goodyear Lake
$2200/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 8
9.8 mi to Dreams Park
10.6 mi to Baseball World
13.5 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE -This waterfront home is indeed a Hidden Treasure.  Located on a large lot in a private location overlooking a cove known for superb bass fishing. Spacious living room and sun room along with open deck all with beautiful calming lake view.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Knoll Top

Canadarago Lake
$1950/week
3br 1.5ba Sleeps 6
18.7 mi to Dreams Park
32.5 mi to Baseball World
31.9 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Awesome summer home on gentle knoll above the lake with majestic view, large lawn – perfect choice for a family vacation. Canoe, kayak and hydro-bike included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Lakeshore Lodge

Goodyear Lake
$1795/week
2br 2ba Sleeps 7
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Lakefront home with balcony overlooking water and waterfront dock. Kayaks(3)included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Lakeside Suite

Goodyear Lake
$850/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
10 mi to Dreams Park
9.8 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Unique private suite located in a private structure. Access to a deck overlooking the lake.  Enjoy the awesome sunset views.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Lakeview Cottage

Goodyear Lake
$1090/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
10 mi to Dreams Park
9.9 mi to Baseball World
12.4 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2003, a relaxing retreat for swimming, boating, and fishing. Canoe, kayak, paddle boat, and rowboat included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Lucky Catch Cove

Canadargo Lake
$2300/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
18.8 mi to Dreams Park
32.5 mi to Baseball World
31.9 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Perched on a knoll with commanding long distance lake view. 2 kayaks, a canoe, and a row boat included, hammock. Outdoor fire pit. Large patio at water's edge and 190 feet of lake frontage.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Morning Glory

Canadargo Lake
$2700/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
13.4 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
26.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Renovated in 2016-17. Phenomenal sunrise start each day with Morning Glory! 250 sq ft covered balcony overlooking lake with eastern view. Great swimming, fishing from private dock.  Row boat and fishing poles and tackle provided.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Point of View

Goodyear Lake
$1490/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.3 mi to Dreams Park
14.2 mi to Baseball World
13.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2006, charming and inviting - two bedroom offering.Quiet location with mature trees. Great bass fishing from the dock.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Riverbend

Goodyear Lake
$3950/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
8.9 mi to Dreams Park
12.3 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Built in 2014, awesome 4 bedroom, 3 bath home enjoys great sunset views,awesome fishing, open floor plan designed for family fun! Game room, paddle boat, private 100 foot waterfront with dock.  Fire pit for family campfires.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Rose Cottage

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
9.1 mi to Baseball World
11.7 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - New interior renovation in 2014. Large wrap around deck and multilevel dock system.  Very accessible waterfront for swimming, fishing and water sports. Beautiful wide water view. Outdoor fire pit.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sandy Cove

Goodyear Lake
$3200/week
3br 3ba Sleeps 7
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.2 mi to Baseball World
11.8 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Renovated in 2014. Very private 3 bedroom home with a quiet child-friendly waterfront. Sandy beach area, paddle boat, basketball hoop, hot tub, and large front yard.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sleeping Lion

Otsego Lake
$3450/week
5br 4ba Sleeps 10
11.3 mi to Dreams Park
30.9 mi to Baseball World
29.9 mi to All Star Village
OTSEGO LAKE -  Nestled in side of gentle hill, this 5 bedroom waterfront offering has  balconies on each level - views from the balconies are awesome!! Waterfront dock is great for fishing and swimming.  Pontoon charters available for extra fee - arrange w/ host. Two fire pits located on terraced lawn.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sunrise Chalet

Canadargo Lake
$1900/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 9
13.2 mi to Dreams Park
27.1 mi to Baseball World
27.3 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New construction in 2007, high quality lodging overlooking the lake. Rowboat with electric motor at private dock across the street. Private deck area at water's edge.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sunset Lake Lodge

Canadargo Lake
$1330/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
15.4 mi to Dreams Park
29.1 mi to Baseball World
28.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Very large yard, 430 ft private waterfront with private dock, fire pit, and canoe.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Sunset Waters

Goodyear Lake
$1950/week
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.6 mi to Baseball World
12.1 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Spacious 3 bedroom waterfront with beautiful sunset views from the patio and from the inside.  Private hot tub, canoe and fishing poles included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

The Loft at Oak Shores

Arnold Lake
$1295/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 3
5.4 mi to Dreams Park
13.9 mi to Baseball World
12.7 mi to All Star Village
ARNOLD LAKE - New construction in 2009, Studio / cottage on Arnold Lake only 10 minutes from the Dreams Park. Inviting ambiance in tranquil setting with private dock.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Thor's Landing

Canadargo Lake
$1300/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
14 mi to Dreams Park
26.3 mi to Baseball World
26.5 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Cozy cottage with deck overlooking the water, with awesome panoramic views.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Trout Brook

Canadargo Lake
$1300-1590/wk
2br 1ba Sleeps 4-6
18.8 mi to Dreams Park
32.3 mi to Baseball World
21.9 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - NEWLY renovated duplex with upscale contemporary interiors. Panoramic lakeviews, fire pit, kayaks, stand-up paddle boards included.

Trout Brook Unit 4 - Second Floor

• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 6
• 1 Bath

• Summer weekly - $1590 + tax

Trout Brook Unit 3 - First Floor
• 2 Bedrooms, sleeps 4
• 1 Bath

• Summer weekly - $1300 + tax

• 18.8 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
• 16.2 miles to Cooperstown
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Trout Brook Unit 4
Trout Brook Unit 3

Wide Waterview

Canadargo Lake
$1330/week
2br 2ba Sleeps 4
14.7 mi to Dreams Park
28.3 mi to Baseball World
27.8 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New renovation in 2012.  Panoramic view of lake from both levels. Large flagstone waterfront patio, private dock, outdoor fireplace for campfires. Your host provides a row boat and 2 kayaks for family fun on the water.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

American Eagle

Water Access Nearby
$1500/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.6 mi to All Star Village
Recent renovation in Goodyear Lake area w/ lake access across the street. Open floor plan. Open rear deck w/ hot tub. Basket ball hoop and fire pit provided. 2 kayaks available.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Beaver Bungalow

Private Pond
$2600/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
22.7 mi to Dreams Park
10.3 mi to Baseball World
6.6 mi to All Star Village
This hidden gem has something for everyone: private, park-like setting w/ in-ground pool, hot tub, large private pond.  Hosts provide row boat, canoe, paddle boat, basketball hoop and a swing set.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Beaver Pond

Private Pond
$1500/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 6
6.4 mi to Dreams Park
15.6 mi to Baseball World
13.8 mi to All Star Village
Recently renovated farmhouse located on gentle knoll overlooking scenic ponds and rolling hills. Fishing and swimming available. Kayak, and basketball hoop included. Awesome, quiet country setting.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Bridgecreek

Water Access Nearby
$2100/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 9
3.7 mi to Dreams Park
23.8 mi to Baseball World
21 mi to All Star Village
Bridgecreek is very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams park and Village of Cooperstown. The 5 acre yard is bordered by Oaks Creek which is great for fishing. Very private, quiet setting. Sports equipment provided. Whole house water filtration.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Brookside

Water Access Nearby
$1990/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.2 mi to Dreams Park
25.5 mi to Baseball World
21.9 mi to All Star Village
Peaceful setting in Hamlet of Fly Creek, overlooking a bubbling stream with good fishing. Game room and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Cardinal Cottage

Water Access Nearby
$1290/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 4
11.8 mi to Dreams Park
31.5 mi to Baseball World
30.5 mi to All Star Village
Charming one level home with inviting decor, north of Cooperstown with water access at shared waterfront dock on Otsego Lake. Large screened in back porch. Serene setting.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Cherry Lane Cottages

Water Access Nearby
$920/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
15.5 mi to Dreams Park
29.5 mi to Baseball World
28.1 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - Charming cottages of new construction in 2009. Two guest cottages just 100 feet from a very child-friendly waterfront. Fire pit and row boat included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST
Cherry Lane Cottage One
Cherry Lane Cottage Two

Cooperstown Junction

Water Access Nearby
$950/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
10 mi to Dreams Park
9.9 mi to Baseball World
12.5 mi to All Star Village
Located in the Goodyear Lake community with lake access.  Fishing poles provided.  Very large level yard, outdoor dining and seating. Basketball hoop & Foosball included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Country Hideaway

Private Pond
$1600/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
12 mi to Dreams Park
19.9 mi to Baseball World
18.5 mi to All Star Village
A perfect getaway in the country with large yard and private pond complete with paddle boat. Quiet, private setting. Game room complete with pool table + air hockey table.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Creek Island

Water Access Nearby
$2500/week
4br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
5.7 mi to Dreams Park
25.4 mi to Baseball World
22.7 mi to All Star Village
Spacious 4 bedroom / 2.5 bath home with large back yard overlooking Oaks Creek.  Fishing is welcomed.  Multiple decks and balconies, very convenient to Cooperstown Dreams Park and to the village of Cooperstown.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Eagle View

Water Access Nearby
$980/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 4
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
10 mi to Baseball World
12.6 mi to All Star Village
Bald Eagles often roost in the tall evergreens by this comfortable two bedroom home.  There is an open deck and a large backyard, complete with fire pit for campfires.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Gardenview

Private Pond
$1250/week
2br 1ba Sleeps 5
24.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.2 mi to Baseball World
5.9 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
Recently built. Located less than 10 minutes from Cooperstown All Star Village with awesome long distance view in picturesque country setting.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Goodyear Retreat

Water Access Nearby
$2000/week
3br 1.5ba Sleeps 6
10 mi to Dreams Park
9.9 mi to Baseball World
12.5 mi to All Star Village
New construction 2016 - 2017. Unique retreat created by talented craftsman. Contemporary, upscale inside and out. Open deck area surrounds the home on 3 sides. Great for all local baseball tournaments. Hot tub on deck.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Hard Rock Ridge

Private Pond
$950/week
1br 1ba Sleeps 5
12.6 mi to Dreams Park
26.3 mi to Baseball World
25.7 mi to All Star Village
One bedroom located on a gentle knoll in peaceful country setting with 1 acre scenic pond, spacious covered deck, matures trees and large yard. Renovated in 2013. Foosball.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

High Valley

Private Pond
$1850/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.6 mi to Dreams Park
18.9 mi to Baseball World
17.6 mi to All Star Village
Hand crafted cabin in country setting overlooking 2 ponds and panoramic valley view.  Adjacent building with game room, full bath and wireless internet access. One of a kind vacation spot!
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Otsego Overlook

Water Access Nearby
$1390/week
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
11.8 mi to Dreams Park
31.4 mi to Baseball World
30.5 mi to All Star Village
NEW Renovation in 2018.  Delightful 3 bedroom cottage with lake access with extensive dock system for great fishing and swimming.  Interior is welcoming country chic style.  Fire pit for campfires under the stars.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Rabbit Run

Private Pond
$3300/week
4br 2ba Sleeps 8
9.3 mi to Dreams Park
18.6 mi to Baseball World
18 mi to All Star Village
Delightful country home - newly renovated in awesome quiet country setting overlooking stocked fishing ponds. Tasteful decor - perfect for the discerning traveler. Game room , basketball hoop, and fishing poles included.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Smiling Pines

Private Pond
$2000/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
11.3 mi to Dreams Park
27.5 mi to Baseball World
26.9 mi to All Star Village
Smiling Pines brings smiles to all who stay there as they enjoy swimming, paddle sports and fishing on a private 3 acre pond. Comfortable, inviting atmosphere in a home with contemporary open floor plan.
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Stoke's Lodge

Private Pond
$2400/week
5br 2ba Sleeps 10
11.7 mi to Dreams Park
11.2 mi to Baseball World
13.7 mi to All Star Village
Vacation home in awesome country setting with private pond.  Enjoy the quiet and watch the wildlife. Central Air
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST

Victory Hill

Private Pond
$1750/week
4br 3ba Sleeps 9
10.1 mi to Dreams Park
13.4 mi to Baseball World
16 mi to All Star Village
Wheelchair Accessible
A frame home with new addition in 2007 on horse farm. Fire pit, Acres of meadows and woods for exploring. Private pond for fishing - fishing gear provided.  Horseback riding lessons available(not included in rental).
Availability In 2019 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
2019 Reservations Begin October 1, 2018
Self-Book Online at Midnight OR by Phone at 9:00 am EST