Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Property Photos
  • Sunset Waters entry walk Sunset Waters entry walk
    Sunset Waters entry walk
  • Sunset Waters lake view Sunset Waters lake view
    Sunset Waters lake view
  • Sunset Waters dock
Sunset Waters dock
    Sunset Waters dock
  • Sunset Waters waterfront Sunset Waters waterfront
    Sunset Waters waterfront

Standard Amenities

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Lakefront

Sunset Waters

Goodyear Lake
$2150/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
10.5 mi to Dreams Park
9.6 mi to Baseball World
12.1 mi to All Star Village
161 Sunnycrest Road
Maryland NY 12116
GPS: 42.50855, -74.98022
GOODYEAR LAKE - Enjoy beautiful sunsets while relaxing in the hot tub overlooking Goodyear Lake, or paddle the canoe around the lake.  The fishing is especially great in this section. Fishing poles are provided. Guests enjoy the waterfront dock for both swimming and fishing.  There is outdoor seating on the dock, or on the stone patio outside your front door and there is a picnic table in the yard. 

Sunset Waters is located in a finished lower level of the hosts' home.  It is a private, spacious 3 bedroom unit with an open floor plan.  The main room includes a dining area, living area and a kitchen. 
 
Your hosts live on the main level (totally separate from your quarters) and are close by if you need assistance. Central Air installed in fall of 2015.

Wireless internet, Central A/C and Hot Tub.

Amenities:
  • 3 Bedrooms, sleeps 6
    All on one level
    1st Bedroom - 1 king
    2nd Bedroom - 1 queen
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
  • 1 Bath w/ tub and shower
  • Wireless internet
  • Central Air
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens p+ towels provided
  • 2 TVs /cable / DVD, incl a flat screen in lv rm and a TV in king bdrm
  • Generally good cell service
  • Kitchen
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Outdoor dining and outdoor seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Stone patio
  • Hot Tub
  • Waterfront dock
  • Canoe
  • Life jackets
  • Fishing poles
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • 1400 square feet

  • 10.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.7 miles to Cooperstown
  • 12.1 miles to All Star Village
  • 9.6 miles to Baseball World

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity:  6 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2150 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit - $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Sunset Waters
5 Stars!
Todd B from NJ - 8/9/2019

Beautiful and peaceful property....being outside overlooking the lake is what it's all about! Kids loved the canoe and swimming. My dad enjoyed just drinking his coffee on the back deck taking in the beauty of the lake and nature. Thank you again!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chena from NY - 8/2/2019

Perfect location, easy travel between dreams park and Cooperstown, best spot on the lake (friends had murky water). Probably the best host I've had in a long time. The house is well equipped inside and out.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Scott from CA - 7/12/2019

Great Owners of the property. Friendly, private, perfect!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from ON - 7/5/2019

Clean premises and immaculate grounds. Beautiful vies with lots to do on the property. Wonderful hosts.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jennifer D from MI - 6/28/2019
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Mike D from PA - 8/24/2018

Yes we would and we already have! The host and hostess were friendly, helpful and were only "there" if we needed them. It was everything we needed for our week in Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tom P from MN - 8/17/2018

Very clean and well stocked home. Short ride to the park. The hot tub was the perfect way to unwind with a cocktail or two after long days watching baseball. The hosts were great and I would both recommend and stay here again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MI - 8/3/2018

Great location on the water and a short drive to Dreams Park. Exceeded all expectations. Owners were very helpful.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brian from IL - 7/6/2018

Excellent location with beautiful view of lake. Rental easily accommodates 6 people. Better than the pictures!!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chris from IL - 6/29/2018

Sunset waters is the perfect place to stay in Cooperstown if you want the trip to be a vacation with more than just baseball. We played at all star village and it was an easy 10-15 minutes to the park. The views from the private deck and pier are amazing. The property gets full sun all afternoon. We floated and relaxed between games. Fishing and swimming are excellent here. The host was great and thought of everything, from fishing poles, to extra floats, and water shoes. If you have any concerns about them living upstairs, don't. Didn't even know they were there. I saw them twice the whole week and it was when I was looking for them with a question. The home is updated, clean, and the hot tub after the long day was perfect. A few people from the team who stopped by couldn't believe how nice the place was. Thanks again to our host Lori and Jon. Can't wait to come back when my younger son plays in Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Michael L from DE - 6/15/2018

This was such a great place to stay while we were in town for the baseball tournament at Dream Park. We had 6 adults in the house and were comfortable - even with only one bathroom! The view and access to the lake are terrific. Great dock. Great patio. We swam and launched paddle boards and canoes easily from the dock. Did I mention the view? One of the best on the lake. John and Lori are so nice and very easy to work with. Even though they live on the top floor they never bother you or get in the way. If you are in town for a tournament you are only 20 minutes from the park. If siblings are with you being on this lake is a great way to keep them entertained! I highly recommend this rental agency, this home owner and this property.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Corey from NY - 8/18/2017

Already referred to a couple people going to dreams park next year. Jon & Lori are awesome, and we loved Sunset Waters.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Robert S from NC - 8/11/2017

Beautiful property, well maintained with an amazing view . John and Lori were awesome hosts. Our sons team played in the championship game during our week , Lori came out to support us at the ball park that night. Great place for your family to relax away from the park!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Bruce P from OH - 7/28/2017

We rented this house for the week my son played at Dreams Field, it was perfect for our family. The property is beautiful and was perfect for everyone else not playing baseball to have a nice lake house for the week. We used the dock and canoe daily, fished and swam in the lake and relaxed in the evening in the hot tub. Jon and Lori were great to work with and available if needed. I would recommend this property to anyone needing a vacation lake house while attending baseball games for week, dreams park is about 10 miles away and this house is super convenient to that and the town of Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lisa R from PA - 7/21/2017

Sunset Waters was very clean, well stocked and comfortable! The owners were friendly and helpful.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Colleen W from IL - 7/7/2017

It was very clean.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Julie B from IL - 6/9/2017

The property was perfect with easy lake access. The owners are on site and addressed any need immediately.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Angie C from IL - 6/2/2017

Very nice and clean place and the owners were very nice. Great location!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Melissa S from NY - 8/26/2016

This place is a hidden gem! Beautiful, peaceful and close to the park. The owners were very helpful and sweet, yet kept to themselves. It was perfect!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Darrin from VA - 8/19/2016

Jon and Lori are just great people and were there for anything during our stay. The lower level is updated, comfortable beds,very clean, and beautiful lake views. I would highly recommend to anyone wanting a family vacation or house while their son plays in Cooperstown. You cannot go wrong renting from Jon or Lori and will love this place

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brett G from IL - 8/12/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Mandi D from TX - 7/15/2016

BEAUTIFUL Scenery and the owners (Jon & Lori) were just AMAZING!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
John H from FL - 6/17/2016

was a great place, great owners, and as expected.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from IL - 6/10/2016

Nice location, clean well maintained home, beautiful lake setting.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Ron M from CA - 8/14/2015

Excellent location. Great Lake access. Clean, nice decor. John and Laurie were gracious hosts. Fantastic hospitality.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brad L from IN - 7/24/2015

Jon & Lori were very accommodating. The rental was very neat and clean, with extras provided as well. I would definitely refer their property to a friend.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Josh from MS - 7/17/2015

Cabin was very nice and cozy. With no a/c the first few nights were tough. Once the weather changed to cool at night it was great. The lake was awesome at anytime. The short distance to the fields were great. I would stay here again hands down.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kristina P from MD - 7/10/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tracy A from IL - 7/3/2015

Jon and Lori greeted us upon arrival. They were very friendly and accommodating. The apartment was very clean. My family enjoyed the hot tub, fishing, and canoe that was available for our use. The landscaping was beautiful. We had everything we needed for an enjoyable stay. I would recommend this rental and intend to return one day.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 6/19/2015

The property was beautifully landscaped on Goodyear Lake. My grandsons loved to fish and canoe on the lake and the adults enjoyed the hot tub on the covered porch since it rained most every day! Everything we needed was included on the property including our own grill for cooking and washer and dryer. Jon and Lori were gracious hosts. We thoroughly enjoyed our week at Sunset Waters and would love to come back again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Amanda C from OH - 6/12/2015

Jon & Lori were so kind and helpful. Great place, great location, great people. Highly recommend!! We stayed here for Dreams Park week but would stay here for fun anytime - location on Goodyear Lake is beautiful!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

GOODYEAR LAKE - Enjoy beautiful sunsets while relaxing in the hot tub overlooking Goodyear Lake, or paddle the canoe around the lake.  The fishing is especially great in this section. Fishing poles are provided. Guests enjoy the waterfront dock for both swimming and fishing.  There is outdoor seating on the dock, or on the stone patio outside your front door and there is a picnic table in the yard. 

Sunset Waters is located in a finished lower level of the hosts' home.  It is a private, spacious 3 bedroom unit with an open floor plan.  The main room includes a dining area, living area and a kitchen. 
 
Your hosts live on the main level (totally separate from your quarters) and are close by if you need assistance. Central Air installed in fall of 2015.

Wireless internet, Central A/C and Hot Tub.

Amenities:
  • 3 Bedrooms, sleeps 6
    All on one level
    1st Bedroom - 1 king
    2nd Bedroom - 1 queen
    3rd Bedroom - 1 queen
  • 1 Bath w/ tub and shower
  • Wireless internet
  • Central Air
  • Washer / dryer + Iron & ironing board
  • Bed linens p+ towels provided
  • 2 TVs /cable / DVD, incl a flat screen in lv rm and a TV in king bdrm
  • Generally good cell service
  • Kitchen
  • Dining area
  • Living area
  • Outdoor dining and outdoor seating
  • Outdoor gas grill
  • Stone patio
  • Hot Tub
  • Waterfront dock
  • Canoe
  • Life jackets
  • Fishing poles
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • 1400 square feet

  • 10.5 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
  • 15.7 miles to Cooperstown
  • 12.1 miles to All Star Village
  • 9.6 miles to Baseball World

  • Please:
    No smoking
    No pets
    No team parties or large gatherings

  • Maximum capacity:  6 people

  • Rates:
    Summer weekly - $2150 + tax
    Refundable damage deposit - $300

Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host. Some hosts will accept the deposit upon arrival and some will ask you to mail it to them before your arrival.

Your host will send you a Welcome Note in the spring with specific details.

Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Sunset Waters
5 Stars!
Todd B from NJ - 8/9/2019

Beautiful and peaceful property....being outside overlooking the lake is what it's all about! Kids loved the canoe and swimming. My dad enjoyed just drinking his coffee on the back deck taking in the beauty of the lake and nature. Thank you again!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chena from NY - 8/2/2019

Perfect location, easy travel between dreams park and Cooperstown, best spot on the lake (friends had murky water). Probably the best host I've had in a long time. The house is well equipped inside and out.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Scott from CA - 7/12/2019

Great Owners of the property. Friendly, private, perfect!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from ON - 7/5/2019

Clean premises and immaculate grounds. Beautiful vies with lots to do on the property. Wonderful hosts.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Jennifer D from MI - 6/28/2019
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Mike D from PA - 8/24/2018

Yes we would and we already have! The host and hostess were friendly, helpful and were only "there" if we needed them. It was everything we needed for our week in Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tom P from MN - 8/17/2018

Very clean and well stocked home. Short ride to the park. The hot tub was the perfect way to unwind with a cocktail or two after long days watching baseball. The hosts were great and I would both recommend and stay here again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from MI - 8/3/2018

Great location on the water and a short drive to Dreams Park. Exceeded all expectations. Owners were very helpful.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brian from IL - 7/6/2018

Excellent location with beautiful view of lake. Rental easily accommodates 6 people. Better than the pictures!!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Chris from IL - 6/29/2018

Sunset waters is the perfect place to stay in Cooperstown if you want the trip to be a vacation with more than just baseball. We played at all star village and it was an easy 10-15 minutes to the park. The views from the private deck and pier are amazing. The property gets full sun all afternoon. We floated and relaxed between games. Fishing and swimming are excellent here. The host was great and thought of everything, from fishing poles, to extra floats, and water shoes. If you have any concerns about them living upstairs, don't. Didn't even know they were there. I saw them twice the whole week and it was when I was looking for them with a question. The home is updated, clean, and the hot tub after the long day was perfect. A few people from the team who stopped by couldn't believe how nice the place was. Thanks again to our host Lori and Jon. Can't wait to come back when my younger son plays in Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Michael L from DE - 6/15/2018

This was such a great place to stay while we were in town for the baseball tournament at Dream Park. We had 6 adults in the house and were comfortable - even with only one bathroom! The view and access to the lake are terrific. Great dock. Great patio. We swam and launched paddle boards and canoes easily from the dock. Did I mention the view? One of the best on the lake. John and Lori are so nice and very easy to work with. Even though they live on the top floor they never bother you or get in the way. If you are in town for a tournament you are only 20 minutes from the park. If siblings are with you being on this lake is a great way to keep them entertained! I highly recommend this rental agency, this home owner and this property.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Corey from NY - 8/18/2017

Already referred to a couple people going to dreams park next year. Jon & Lori are awesome, and we loved Sunset Waters.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Robert S from NC - 8/11/2017

Beautiful property, well maintained with an amazing view . John and Lori were awesome hosts. Our sons team played in the championship game during our week , Lori came out to support us at the ball park that night. Great place for your family to relax away from the park!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Bruce P from OH - 7/28/2017

We rented this house for the week my son played at Dreams Field, it was perfect for our family. The property is beautiful and was perfect for everyone else not playing baseball to have a nice lake house for the week. We used the dock and canoe daily, fished and swam in the lake and relaxed in the evening in the hot tub. Jon and Lori were great to work with and available if needed. I would recommend this property to anyone needing a vacation lake house while attending baseball games for week, dreams park is about 10 miles away and this house is super convenient to that and the town of Cooperstown.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Lisa R from PA - 7/21/2017

Sunset Waters was very clean, well stocked and comfortable! The owners were friendly and helpful.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Colleen W from IL - 7/7/2017

It was very clean.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Julie B from IL - 6/9/2017

The property was perfect with easy lake access. The owners are on site and addressed any need immediately.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Angie C from IL - 6/2/2017

Very nice and clean place and the owners were very nice. Great location!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Melissa S from NY - 8/26/2016

This place is a hidden gem! Beautiful, peaceful and close to the park. The owners were very helpful and sweet, yet kept to themselves. It was perfect!!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Darrin from VA - 8/19/2016

Jon and Lori are just great people and were there for anything during our stay. The lower level is updated, comfortable beds,very clean, and beautiful lake views. I would highly recommend to anyone wanting a family vacation or house while their son plays in Cooperstown. You cannot go wrong renting from Jon or Lori and will love this place

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brett G from IL - 8/12/2016
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Mandi D from TX - 7/15/2016

BEAUTIFUL Scenery and the owners (Jon & Lori) were just AMAZING!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
John H from FL - 6/17/2016

was a great place, great owners, and as expected.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from IL - 6/10/2016

Nice location, clean well maintained home, beautiful lake setting.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Ron M from CA - 8/14/2015

Excellent location. Great Lake access. Clean, nice decor. John and Laurie were gracious hosts. Fantastic hospitality.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Brad L from IN - 7/24/2015

Jon & Lori were very accommodating. The rental was very neat and clean, with extras provided as well. I would definitely refer their property to a friend.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
4 Stars!
Josh from MS - 7/17/2015

Cabin was very nice and cozy. With no a/c the first few nights were tough. Once the weather changed to cool at night it was great. The lake was awesome at anytime. The short distance to the fields were great. I would stay here again hands down.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Kristina P from MD - 7/10/2015
Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Tracy A from IL - 7/3/2015

Jon and Lori greeted us upon arrival. They were very friendly and accommodating. The apartment was very clean. My family enjoyed the hot tub, fishing, and canoe that was available for our use. The landscaping was beautiful. We had everything we needed for an enjoyable stay. I would recommend this rental and intend to return one day.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Guest from PA - 6/19/2015

The property was beautifully landscaped on Goodyear Lake. My grandsons loved to fish and canoe on the lake and the adults enjoyed the hot tub on the covered porch since it rained most every day! Everything we needed was included on the property including our own grill for cooking and washer and dryer. Jon and Lori were gracious hosts. We thoroughly enjoyed our week at Sunset Waters and would love to come back again.

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes
5 Stars!
Amanda C from OH - 6/12/2015

Jon & Lori were so kind and helpful. Great place, great location, great people. Highly recommend!! We stayed here for Dreams Park week but would stay here for fun anytime - location on Goodyear Lake is beautiful!

Would you recommend to a friend? Yes

Use the buttons below to share this property

Questions? Looking for Something in Particular?

For assistance, call 607-547-6260 or send us an email

More Property Photos
  • Sunset Waters living and dining area Sunset Waters living and dining area
    Sunset Waters living and dining area
  • Sunset Waters seating area Sunset Waters seating area
    Sunset Waters seating area
  • Sunset Waters seating area Sunset Waters seating area
    Sunset Waters seating area
  • Sunset Waters dining area Sunset Waters dining area
    Sunset Waters dining area
  • Sunset Waters kitchen Sunset Waters kitchen
    Sunset Waters kitchen
  • Sunset Waters kitchen Sunset Waters kitchen
    Sunset Waters kitchen
  • Sunset Waters bedroom Sunset Waters bedroom
    Sunset Waters bedroom
  • Sunset Waters bedroom Sunset Waters bedroom
    Sunset Waters bedroom
  • Sunset Waters bedroom Sunset Waters bedroom
    Sunset Waters bedroom
  • Sunset Waters bath Sunset Waters bath
    Sunset Waters bath
  • Sunset Waters bath and laundry Sunset Waters bath and laundry
    Sunset Waters bath and laundry