3 Bedroom House Rentals in Cooperstown, NY

We have 3 bedroom home rentals in Cooperstown for your family. Find lodging near Cooperstown Dreams Park and All Star Village. Call to speak with a local Cooperstown resident to assist with your decision. Or, book online!

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter any/part of the property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:

- Bed linens, blankets, pillows

- Bath towels

- Television with Cable or Satellite

All other amenities are included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!



Note:
1.  Refundable damage deposit is separate from rental fee and is paid directly to your host.

2. Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless it is specifically listed.

3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Private Homes / 3 Bedrooms

1819 Carriage House

$1600/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 6
1.7 mi to Dreams Park
14.6 mi to Baseball World
15.2 mi to All Star Village
Recently renovated carriage house on same property as the 1819 House. Close to Dreams Park.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

42 North

$2490/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 10
13.2 mi to Dreams Park
24 mi to Baseball World
25.1 mi to All Star Village
Newly renovated in 2012. Log Cabin style home with tasteful, well chosen decor. Large game room with 6' pool table. Exquisite home for the discerning traveler. 42 North Apartment also on same property.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Al's Ranch

$1290/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 5
7.7 mi to Dreams Park
11.6 mi to Baseball World
11 mi to All Star Village
Delightful custom built home set on a very private 5 acre wooded lot. Outdoor fire pit. Guest cottage on same property has 1 bdrm +1 bath. Perfect choice for those who enjoy peaceful country setting.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

American Eagle

Water Access Nearby
$1500/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
10.2 mi to Dreams Park
10.2 mi to Baseball World
12.6 mi to All Star Village
Recent renovation in Goodyear Lake area w/ lake access across the street. Open floor plan. Open rear deck w/ hot tub. Basket ball hoop and fire pit provided. 2 kayaks available.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Applewood

$1700/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
0 mi to Dreams Park
19.7 mi to Baseball World
19.6 mi to All Star Village
Very convenient to Dreams Park, 3 bedroom, 2 bath with very large yard with outdoor fire pit for family campfires.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

August Garden

$1600/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
7.3 mi to Dreams Park
14.9 mi to Baseball World
15.4 mi to All Star Village
Renovated in 2002 immaculate home in residential section of Hartwick, with spacious rear deck, a wonderful backyard for your relaxation, and Gourmet kitchen.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Bateman Cottage

$1600/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 7
4.7 mi to Dreams Park
24.4 mi to Baseball World
24.3 mi to All Star Village
NEW construction, quiet residential section. Large wrap around deck for outside dining. Contemporary decor. Game room w/ Foosball. Very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Bavarian Farm

$2200/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 9
9.5 mi to Dreams Park
28.9 mi to Baseball World
28.7 mi to All Star Village
New construction - Exquisite home in immaculate condition, with awesome long distance view of rolling hills and valley, large wrap around deck for outdoor dining and seating. Bavarian Farm Apartment and Bavarian Farm Studio, are separate units on the same property.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Bucks Run

$1700/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
8 mi to Dreams Park
22.7 mi to Baseball World
22.6 mi to All Star Village
Built in 2006, 2200 sq ft ranch home with awesome long distance view of the valley and rolling hills. Private setting convenient to Dreams Park and Cooperstown.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Butts Mountain

$1600/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
4 mi to Dreams Park
13.9 mi to Baseball World
14.3 mi to All Star Village
Ranch house with long distance view overlooking valley with scenic ponds stocked with fish.  Very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park. Paddle boat and row boat available for fun on the ponds. Fishing welcome.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Carol's Kitchen Huddle

$1200/week
3br 1ba Sleeps 6
6.8 mi to Dreams Park
13.7 mi to Baseball World
16.2 mi to All Star Village
This inviting comfortable country home is nestled on a side knoll with a soothing view of a peaceful valley with the hills beyond. Front deck and rear patio. Fire pit and basketball hoop.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Changing Seasons

$1400/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
6.8 mi to Dreams Park
16.2 mi to Baseball World
14.9 mi to All Star Village
Welcoming 3 bedroom ranch in country setting.  Immaculate condition. Game room with pool table.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Cider House

$2300/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.7 mi to Dreams Park
26 mi to Baseball World
28 mi to All Star Village
Renovated in 2011, located on property of Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard. $50 Gift Card & gifts from the Cider Mill included. Charming home next to Cider Mill, home of the best home made fudge and aged cheese.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Cooperstown Cottage

$1580/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
1.8 mi to Dreams Park
21.2 mi to Baseball World
20.1 mi to All Star Village
Three bedroom, 2 bath home, conveniently located between the Cooperstown Dreams Park and Cooperstown.  Above ground pool.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Country Daze

$1700/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
5.8 mi to Dreams Park
15.3 mi to Baseball World
17.3 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2000, spacious ranch home with awesome long distance view of rolling hills and well manicured perennial flower gardens.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Creekside

$1700/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
6.3 mi to Dreams Park
14.4 mi to Baseball World
13.1 mi to All Star Village
Built in 2007, a contemporary home overlooking scenic pond, large yard in country setting. A small meandering stream at edge of property.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Curry Court

$1950/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
3.6 mi to Dreams Park
15.7 mi to Baseball World
15.5 mi to All Star Village
Ranch home very convenient to Dreams Park. Above ground pool and wireless internet access.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Day House

$1300/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
6 mi to Dreams Park
20.8 mi to Baseball World
19.5 mi to All Star Village
Immaculate three bedroom two bath, two story home in hamlet of Fly Creek, very convenient to Dreams Park and Cooperstown. 
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Doc Graham

$2350/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 10
0.3 mi to Dreams Park
19.8 mi to Baseball World
19.7 mi to All Star Village
Doc Graham neighbors Moonlight Graham. Ideal for families who wish to be near each other and still have privacy. Both recently renovated. Shared backyard including a stream, a fire pit, horse shoe pit and an above ground pool.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Dreamview

$1690/week
3br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
13 mi to Dreams Park
13 mi to Baseball World
12.5 mi to All Star Village
New construction in 2008. Charming Cape Cod style home on a side hill with awesome long distance views. Spacious rooms. Large front deck for dining and relaxing.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Goodyear Retreat

Water Access Nearby
$2000/week
3br 1.5ba Sleeps 6
10 mi to Dreams Park
9.9 mi to Baseball World
12.5 mi to All Star Village
New construction 2016 - 2017. Unique retreat created by talented craftsman. Contemporary, upscale inside and out. Open deck area surrounds the home on 3 sides. Great for all local baseball tournaments. Hot tub on deck.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Groveside

$1350/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 7
10.6 mi to Dreams Park
14 mi to Baseball World
16.6 mi to All Star Village
Built in 2006.  Spacious 1800 square foot with large yard, located at edge of a lightly wooded area. Perfect choice for families seeking a pristine, quiet country setting.  Fire pit for enjoying campfires under the stars.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

High Valley

Private Pond
$1850/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 8
6.6 mi to Dreams Park
18.9 mi to Baseball World
17.6 mi to All Star Village
Hand crafted cabin in country setting overlooking 2 ponds and panoramic valley view.  Adjacent building with game room, full bath and wireless internet access. One of a kind vacation spot!
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Hilltop House

$1280/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
8.2 mi to Dreams Park
9.4 mi to Baseball World
8 mi to All Star Village
Three bedroom two bath, modern vacation home with spectacular panoramic valley view. Located in a peaceful country setting, makes relaxing easy.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

JR's Place

$1500/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
4.4 mi to Dreams Park
22.5 mi to Baseball World
22.9 mi to All Star Village
Updated in 2010, and very convenient to Dreams Park and the Village of Cooperstown. Large yard, adjacent to fishing stream. Fishing welcome.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Kenwood

$1600/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
1.4 mi to Dreams Park
20.8 mi to Baseball World
20.6 mi to All Star Village
Charming 3 bedroom and 2 bath vintage home very close to Dreams Park, large back yard. Inviting decor.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

Knotty Pine

$1460/week
3br 2ba Sleeps 6
6.8 mi to Dreams Park
12.8 mi to Baseball World
11.5 mi to All Star Village
A very private country retreat in pristine condition. Perfect choice for traveler who enjoys privacy in a quiet setting. Fire pit.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31

La Virginia

$2800/week
3br 3ba Sleeps 10
0.4 mi to Dreams Park
20 mi to Baseball World
19.9 mi to All Star Village
Renovated in 2015 with tasteful, well chosen contemporary decor.  Hardwood and tile floors throughout. Less than a half mile to Dreams Park - very convenient. Complete w/ game room, outdoor fire pit and stone fireplace.
Availability In 2018 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/1
to
6/8
6/8
to
6/15
6/15
to
6/22
6/22
to
6/29
6/29
to
7/6
7/6
to
7/13
7/13
to
7/20
7/20
to
7/27
7/27
to
8/3
8/3
to
8/10
8/10
to
8/17
8/17
to
8/24
8/24
to
8/31