5 Bedroom House Rentals in Cooperstown, NY

Need a large 5 bedroom house rental in Cooperstown for your large family? Whatever your accommodation needs are, we've got large homes for rent near the Dreams Park. Search our site or call for friendly, local assistance.

Have a Question? Get Personal Help from Rental Experts who Live in Cooperstown!

Lodging Options
Search Lodging

Find Specific Property

Enter property name or address

Area Information
Rental Information
VISA, MasterCard, Discover
Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:
  • Bed linens, blankets, pillows
  • Bath linens
  • TV / Cable or Satellite, Internet
  • Fully equipped kitchen
All other amenities  included ONLY if specifically listed in the full description for the property!

Note:
  1. Refundable damage deposit - separate from rental fee.
    Paid directly to  host.
  2.  Rental units are NOT handicap accessible unless  specifically listed.
  3.  Each property is managed by the host / owner; Cooperstown Stay is the rental agent.

Cooperstown Stay Private Homes / 5 Bedrooms

1 Apple Hill

$4750/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 14
10 mi to Dreams Park
29.8 mi to Baseball World
28.7 mi to All Star Village
New Construction. 4700 square foot home of contemporary style w/ expansive wrap-around deck and heated in-ground pool. Set on gentle knoll with 6 acre well maintained lawn complete with scenic pond and chipping green. 
This home includes a 1 bedroom apartment on lower level with a fully equipped kitchen, bedroom, living area and bath  - great choice for those who want an area close to others but with some privacy.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Birch Meadow

$4800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
5.9 mi to Dreams Park
16.7 mi to Baseball World
16.1 mi to All Star Village
Meticulous contemporary home with large lawn, spacious rear decks, open floor plan and delightful eclectic décor.  In ground pool.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Country Charm

$2590/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 11
7.9 mi to Dreams Park
17 mi to Baseball World
15 mi to All Star Village
Renovated in 2012, gracious and inviting home in a country village setting.  Wrap-around rear deck overlooking spacious back yard. Game room with foosball, air hockey, dartboard and ping-pong table.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Creekside Farm

$3500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
12.9 mi to Dreams Park
22.7 mi to Baseball World
22.2 mi to All Star Village
Fun for the whole family - in ground pool, 1500 square foot cabana by the pool with dining and seating. basketball hoop and fire pit for campfires under the stars.  
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Doyle House

$2950/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
3.9 mi to Dreams Park
16.1 mi to Baseball World
15.9 mi to All Star Village
Contemporary decor within spacious, vintage home in quiet residential area of Milford - very convenient to the Dreams Park. Lots of space for a family inside and out.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Edgewood

$2900/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
5.5 mi to Dreams Park
16.1 mi to Baseball World
12.9 mi to All Star Village
New construction. Quality built colonial style home in private country setting. Scenic pond in back yard, basketball hoop and fire pit.  Game room.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Pine Grove

$2800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 12
10.3 mi to Dreams Park
23.2 mi to Baseball World
24.3 mi to All Star Village
Renovated in 2010, gracious home with open floor plan, located in country setting. One well supervised team party welcome. Basketball hoop, 8 stocked ponds - great fishing!
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Quiet Time Farm

$3950/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 4.5ba Sleeps 10
7 mi to Dreams Park
21.6 mi to Baseball World
23.6 mi to All Star Village
Magnificent log home built in 2008 in private setting very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Stoke's Lodge

Private Pond
$2690/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 2ba Sleeps 10
11.7 mi to Dreams Park
11.2 mi to Baseball World
13.7 mi to All Star Village
Vacation home in awesome country setting with private pond.  Enjoy the quiet and watch the wildlife. Central Air
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Terrace Lawn

$4350/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
0.6 mi to Dreams Park
19.8 mi to Baseball World
19.6 mi to All Star Village
Spacious country home, recently renovated. Great location very close to Dreams Park and Cooperstown. In ground pool(new in 2016)and large side yard for baseball.

Check out neighboring rentals: Terrace Lawn Cabin and Sunnyside Apt 
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

The Weathervane

$3800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 11
3.8 mi to Dreams Park
15.8 mi to Baseball World
15.3 mi to All Star Village
Vintage home, lovingly restored in immaculate condition with modern amenities in village of Milford. Very convenient to Dreams Park. Above ground pool.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Woodlands

$5000/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
9.9 mi to Dreams Park
25.4 mi to Baseball World
25.9 mi to All Star Village
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Awesome Hills

$3500/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
18 mi to Dreams Park
6.2 mi to Baseball World
2.5 mi to All Star Village
Awesome Hills is a 5 bedroom with 3 baths with showers and 2 half baths. It is a gracious upscale home w/ tasteful well chosen decor - all in immaculate condition. Large stone patio w/ fountain - all overlooking panoramic view of rollings hills. Game room complete w/ Wii, Foosball, and 50" plasma TV. There are 3 baths with showers and 2 more half-baths.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Bellevue Ranch

$4300/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 2.5ba Sleeps 10
21.6 mi to Dreams Park
11.7 mi to Baseball World
8.4 mi to All Star Village
New renovation, two story home with awesome long distance view, in private country setting,  expansive yard basketball hoop, and 50 acres with walking trails. Pavilion on spacious patio in pool area. One well supervised team gathering welcomed.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Brockway's Homestead

$4800/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 4ba Sleeps 10
20.7 mi to Dreams Park
7.7 mi to Baseball World
4.4 mi to All Star Village
Total renovation in 2018-19. Awesome country home very convenient to All Star Village.  Spacious rooms w/ well chosen decor and modern amenities.
There are 4 bedrooms, including a 2 bedroom suite for a total of 5 bedrooms and 4 baths. Game room, basketball hoop, 8 TVs - all for family fun. One well supervised team party welcome.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Cloudscape

$3850/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
20.4 mi to Dreams Park
4.5 mi to Baseball World
1.8 mi to All Star Village
Contemporary home in awesome setting w/ long distance views of rolling hills. Spacious rooms. Above ground pool, fire pit and basketball hoop included. Less than 5 minutes to All Star Village.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Beau Rivage

Riverfront
$4200/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3.5ba Sleeps 10
8.4 mi to Dreams Park
11.5 mi to Baseball World
14.1 mi to All Star Village
SUSQUEHANNA RIVER - Riverfront home located on the Susquehanna River at the head of  Goodyear Lake.  Major renovation 2016-2017. Tandem kayak, stand-up paddle board, paddle boat and canoe included. Free lessons for kayak and SUP from Kayak Shop next door. One well supervised team party.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Blue Heron

Goodyear Lake
$3100/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 2.5ba Sleeps 9
7.4 mi to Dreams Park
11 mi to Baseball World
13 mi to All Star Village
GOODYEAR LAKE - Charming, welcoming, ideal for families. Spacious lawn on private peninsula with 600 feet of waterfront. Paddle boat and canoe included. One of area's best fishing areas.Convenient to baseball tournaments in Cooperstown and Oneonta.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Heron Landing

Canadargo Lake
$4200/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 3ba Sleeps 10
16.3 mi to Dreams Park
29.9 mi to Baseball World
29.4 mi to All Star Village
CANADARAGO LAKE - New construction, luxurious large home w/430 feet of private waterfront and beautiful panoramic views. Game room in separate building + basketball hoop.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4

Sleeping Lion

Otsego Lake
$3450/week
Plus tax. NO additional fees
5br 4ba Sleeps 10
11.3 mi to Dreams Park
30.9 mi to Baseball World
29.9 mi to All Star Village
OTSEGO LAKE -  Nestled in side of gentle hill, this 5 bedroom waterfront offering has  balconies on each level - views from the balconies are awesome!! Waterfront dock is great for fishing and swimming.  Pontoon charters available for extra fee - arrange w/ host. Two fire pits located on terraced lawn.
Availability In 2020 Season
Chart Always Current
Available
On Hold
Not Available
Click to BOOK
6/5
to
6/12
6/12
to
6/19
6/19
to
6/26
6/26
to
7/3
7/3
to
7/10
7/10
to
7/17
7/17
to
7/24
7/24
to
7/31
7/31
to
8/7
8/7
to
8/14
8/14
to
8/21
8/21
to
8/28
8/28
to
9/4